A Brooklyn Pizzeria, San Diego CA

Joseph making the pie with Tony? At the counter. Great experience! Throw back NYC style pie palace. Great pizza, fair price, engaged staff and tasty pizza.

Great pizza, great people. (Great stromboli, too.). I was in town for a week, and ate here four days in a row.

Called store due to help wanted sign and man rudely hung up. Called back and they let ring.

Really enjoyed this restaurant and the employee (owner?) that served us. Our kids were hungry after a tour of the Midway Museum and couldn't agree on anything to eat except pizza, so we found this place. There is a large homeless population right around the restaurant and across the street, which we were a bit put off by at first. The restaurant is small and simple inside, but the pizza was delicious and our kids loved it. They really enjoyed being able to get pizza by the slice, so everyone could have what they wanted. The slices were loaded into the brick oven and served nice and hot! Definitely recommended if you prefer a simple ambiance and good food.

DO NOT ORDER ONLINE! Their website links to an outside company (MenuStar) that will charge you but never put your order through. MenuStar has no customer service and the guys at the restaurant will just tell you that it's not their problem and to take it up with MenuStar and/or your credit card company.

The sauce is to die for. I love this pizzeria. I always get a cheese slice. I wish they had just pineapple cheese. Delicious!

I tried to order a pizza and I was told that chef was not there and they could not make my pizza. This was at noon. I said I would wait then I was told they didn't have the toppings I wanted.

This is my favorite pizza in town! I wish the owner would give me a part time job here! Love it.

Been coming here since I was a kid the owners are always super friendly and welcoming my favorite pizza spot in sd!

Absolutely amazing authentic tasting NY pizza! Definitely the best I've had in San Diego! The owners were SO friendly and helpful, greeting us with a free sample of garlic knots, and just all around being extremely friendly the entire visit.

The prices are extremely affordable, the places has a home feeling, but of course above all its just delicious! Check it out, you wont regret it!

New review: no longer deserves 5 stars, I didn't want to come back and edit my review but this place is very unreliable. They never answer their phone so it is extremely hard to place an order in advance. Their online ordering never works and always says the place is closed. The pizza is so good. I truly believe the only reason they never have business is because of how hard it is to place an order over the phone. I come here all the time and eat inside but today I wanted a whole pizza to take home instead of eating a slice there. No luck.
Old review: Best pizza place in SD! I live in the Little Italy area of San Diego and this place is still better than the pizza places I live next to (Landini's, Filippi's, etc.)
A Brooklyn Pizzeria makes pizza for the people who love the classic taste & greasiness of pizza and crispy crust! Their crust is my favorite, NEVER soggy!
This place also offers stromboli, calzones, salads, and he can make you any pizza you want! If you like tasty pizza and kind service, this place is for you! Food is always fresh, I have never been disappointed. 10/10
I am very grateful he gave me a chance to see his work station, I have never met someone so passionate about their craft. Amazing experience!

Pizza is dryyyyyyyyyy. Dry! Ordering from the display is a bad idea. Comparison saltine cracker texture. Not enough tomato sauce.

This place was amazing the pizza was delicious (I got pepperoni pizza) and the “bread sticks” were great I could eat them every day and I wouldn’t get tired of them overall a great experience I would recommend to go there if you can

It's pre-cooked pizza that's warmed for you while you wait. Pizza was ok, I knew what I was getting into.