Paul's Live From New York Pizza, Eureka CA

Yuk. Got slices. They were dry. Very sparse toppings. Place was dirty. Just came from New York where we had a slice at Joe's. This is NOT great news York pizza

Really good food and fast service. I recommend the godfather! Only reason I did 4 star is because they don’t have Apple Pay, even the tiny ghetto corner stores have apply pay so I’m wondering what’s holding them back from it.

I am a regular at Paul’s! Hands-down the best pizza in town! Service is always great. Restaurant is always clean and pizzas always cooked just right! My favorite is the Godmother! Although it’s more popularly referred to as the Godfather. The gluten-free crust is amazing!

These guys are doing pizza right giant pies and slices new York style and à New location I fortuna check it out

Excellent, even astoundingly satisfying pizza. Very tasty. And the slices are huge! And affordable. Friendly staff

Had a bad experience in this place. The pizza is below average (had eaten better frozen pizzas). Go to Domino’s down the street. Had to wait 40 minutes. We went with a service dog and did not meet the ADA requirements. I am filing a complaint next. AVOID THIS PLACE

With the answer from the owner I see he is also a Liar! We even showed him the certificate even if he does not have the right to ask for it. Terrible place and worst management!

Paul's is the only pizza place I've been to in CA that could survive in New York. They'd do much better than survive though, this pizza is good as any slice I've had in NYC. And if my review doesn't convince you, Paul has a stamp of approval from the goodfella himself, Henry Hill.

The staff was so lovely and the pizza was delicious! We got just a Hawaiian pizza, and the dough was perfect texture.a little crunchy but soft. The toppings were delicious and the sauce was zesty! Best way to eat it is definitely folding it like a taco! My boyfriend and I had some fun messing around on the ancient arcade machine while we waited.though it is definitely worse for wear and hardly worked. But I highly recommend the garlic knots! Those were delicious! All around great pizza place with friendly, casual staff

The sausage sandwich with peppers and onions with red sauce! Bomb! Sausage is true new york italian spicy sausage! With Garlic knots, fahgetaboutit

The pizza is just ok. The treat I received with my service dog is unacceptable. I had a person standing in front of me without moving, asking for a physical proof to prove that my dog is a service animal (that’s forbidden mr!). I didn’t want a fight, I thought I would eat a decent pizza… so I proceeded to look for the documents in my mobile phone. As it’s new it took me a bit, I offered the guy to give me a minute and I would reach out to him. He said no, and stood up right in front of me looking me in a bad way and making me feel anxious. My dog is a psychiatric service dog… I should’ve record the whole thing or called the police. Please do it if you go with your service dog and you are treated this way. The pizza wasn’t even good… a frozen one is better.

Excellent pizza, and the garlic knots were unbelievable! Service was friendly, prices are fair. We do recommend Paul's Pizza, it's delicious!

Absolutely loved it! Best pizza I have had in a long time. Really enjoyed the environment. And the customer service was fantastic! Definitely a great place to grab a good slice!

I like their pizza here for lunch time. I had the "Rumble in da Bronx" and "New Amsterdam" slices. Both are awesome. The people who work there are cool. Always had a good time for a lunch break.

Although a bit expensive, Paul's in my opinion has the best pizza in the entire north coast.

Love the large pieces of pizza. I really dig the sauce and ample cheese. I could have used a little more pepperoni though. The vibe is chill but bustling with busyness. Lots too do in immediate area. Quick walk to anywhere in old town!

We were in Eureka for only 2 nights and ate here 3 times. It's that good! It's the best New York style pizza I've had outside of NY!