Angelico Pizzeria, Washington DC

Ordered food for dinner with my family the night of 2/3/23. When I went to pick up my food I was hesitant about leaving without checking my to go order to make sure everything was there! While I was doing so, the man working that night said “everything is in there” and I trusted him. When I went home I opened the bag, my blue cheese was not included with my 10 piece wing order! That completely ruins my wing experience with no sauce? ! Wings with no sauce! Really? ! Terrible experience, DOUBLE CHECK YOUR TOGO ORDER EVEN IF THE STAFF SAY EVERYTHING IS THERE! They lie!

The worst service and worst chicken wings I have ever tasted. Although I clearly mentioned that it was not a take out and I was having my meal at the table he still brought two tightly knotted bags and told me “it’s a lot of food”.
I struggled to open the bags to find absolutely horrible tasting chicken wings. It tasted like discarded bird wings meant for animal consumption, not humans, carelessly slabbed with buffalo sauce straight from the fridge.
Oh, and do not tip in advance. They didn’t deserve a dime for that humiliating service and 40$ wasted on garbage food.

Took them SoOooo Long to Prepare the food! 30 minutes! No wonder no one is ordering from them.

Four dollars for something that can break your tooth, The piece was very short I feel like a kid receiving something for my birthday in the middle of the class it’s not a good ocean definitely many’s pizza it’s much better

Soooooooo good and an actually good size pizza for a family of 4. Found this place based of a relative who use to come here A LOT I agree with her too it's bomb pizza

The guy at the register was so rude about me paying with Apple Pay. I ordered here three days ago no problem paying with Apple Pay then today it was a different guy from my first time he was very rude about using Apple Pay the pizza is great the customer service sucks be better …

Tiny, mediocre pizza delivered ice cold, absolutely awful, stringy, tasteless wings that we had to throw out after two bites, and stale cannoli like cardboard. This is what we received for the privilege of paying over $50. Never again.

Food was good got a very good calzone was ready quickly, highly recommend for a take out spot

We heard a lot of good things about this place and our expectations were pretty high but sadly we end up very disappointed. We had 10 Angelico's Wings and they were awful, not cooked all the way through. My wife's Fettucino Alfredo was very creamy and bland. Apart from the food been unpleasant, the person working there by the name of Alex is absolutely nasty. He was touching his noise while handing people's pickup orders, and didn't even bother to wear a mask nor wash his hands. He has a very bad attitude, unprofessional, and needs to either work on his work ethics or simply be replaced. We will give this place another try in the future.

Ordered take out well in advance (at least 2 hours in advance) and was told that it would be ready before the pick up time. When I showed up, nobody was at the front. I saw that people in the back clearly saw me. Nobody came up front to assist. So after waiting 5 mins, asked if anybody could help and that I had ordered pick up. They said that somebody would come up front. Waited probably another 10 mins. Inly when the phone rang, did somebody come up to answer. I told the guy that I had ordered pick up. He finally checked and said that it was ready? Why make someone wait for takeout when it was ready? What's with the lack of customer these days? I thought the food industry was suffering. Apparently these guys are doing well enough not to take care of the customers.

I went to order a pizza to take away. I ordered an xtra large split half way as a veggie and half as a spicy meatlovers. When I was waiting I was reading the reviews in here and I was thinking, "oh man, what have I gotten myself into? " because of all of the negative reviews. I was handed the big box with my pizza inside, walked home with it, and discovered a very good, world class pizza! The crust was just right. The sauce was just right. The toppings were excellent, and we thoroughly enjoyed it. Keep making excellent pizzas!

The wrist service I gave your delivery man 5 dollars and for what I didn't get my order my pizza didn't come with what I ordered on it and then my pasta came with bread but my bread had a bug on it.then my pizza wasn't made properly just very unsatisfied with everything I don't understand why anybody is giving them a four or five star when they don't deserve that nor do they deserve a one star y'all should be ashamed of y'all selves

First, 5 stars on delivery time. I ordered online at 7: 09 and the delivery guy arrived at 7: 35 (on a Wednesday night).
The knocked off stars were because the supreme pizza was just meh, especially for the price. The toppings were bland and I just wasn’t impressed. The crust was thick and fluffy though, which I liked.

Mediocre at best. Similar in taste and texture to Olga's and Mannys also mids. Oh well.

So Square Pie Guys has been on my list for so long now, but for some reason I could never get anyone to try it with me? No idea why, but I finally decided I was just going to buy a pizza for myself.

I got the How Mush-Room ($24.15) with a side of green goddess dressing ($3) and mike's hot honey ($1.85). This pizza is AMAZING. Usually I am a thin crust pizza gal, but this pizza's outside is so crispy and so much flavor and toppings on the pizza it didn't feel like you were just eating bread.loved that garlic ricotta cream. The green goddess dressing is an amazing addition and I think it would be good on any pizza. My favorite though is this hot honey, it helps to balance out the saltiness of the pizza and adds just a touch of a kick.

Yes, I ate the entire pizza myself! I will say I do think that it is a steep price for the size because I could definitely eat it alone (maybe good for 2 people). That being said, still a huge fan and would come back for a splurge.

Quick delivery and usually accurate with orders, if you want an inexpensive good tasting pizza, this is the place.

Delivery took over an hour. No one reached out tolet us know.
Food was barely warm. Low quality.
Overpriced.