Captain Cookie & the Milkman, Washington DC

DO NOT GO here if you are VEGAN. THIS IS NOT A VEGAN FRIENDLY ESTABLISHMENT. THEY DO NOT HAVE VEGAN ICE CREAM OR ANY VEGAN OPTION OUTSIDE OF A VEGAN CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE. I’m a progressive city on a college campus no less I’d expect a lot more? DO NOT waste your time with this business.

This place never disappoints! Amazing service, fantastic cookies, and great cookie sandwiches.

While the location isn't ideal as there isn't much else around the small "food hall", the cookies are exceptional. With $2/cookie and milk options for a late night treat. They also have a lot of different classic ice cream options to make ice cream cookie sandwiches.

Would highly recommend eating here or trying out one of their other locations!

The cookies are average. I would go to Insomnia over here, to be honest. They were small and toed the line of not enough sweetness to them, in my opinion.

Ordered the ice cream sandwich, the taste was very good. We sat outside and ate it. I highly recommend it.

This location has just completely gone downhill. It’s unappealing, staff is unfriendly and it just looks dirty. No one it’s always empty at Tastemakers. Nothing looks appealing on the counter, ice cream doesn’t look fresh (and for the price it should) and cookies never seem to be fresh baked when I come in. Used to love their food truck and stopping by this location when it first opened but it’s just a dump now. It needs a spruce up to say the least.

Darnell the GM at the NE location absolutely saved our event today. There was an honest mistake made by the delivery driver, but Darnell rushed the correct order to our office and hand delivered the cookies! He was incredibly helpful and kind throughout the whole situation — y’all got a gem working here!

They have the best tasting cookies! I had an oatmeal raisin cookie and a peanut butter one. I highly recommend their product!