Blue Marlin Jewelry, Islamorada FL

Pleasant, friendly. Second time we have shopped in the store, beautiful merchandise. Pleased with our purchases. Jason cleaned our jewelry while we were shopping.

Wide selection that features some very nice lines of jewelry.
Staff is very helpful.

Kind and knowledgeable, the entire team provides a welcoming environment and an extraordinary selection. The perfect place to find a keepsake!

I have been shopping with Blue Marlin for about 10 years. They have high quality items. I trust them to not only repair my special pieces but to help create with me! They assisted in replicating my recently passed (102yr) grandmothers bracelet as an everyday anklet. We also trust them with our antique engagement ring- they are knowledgeable and understand the beauty in old as well as new.

Absolutely fabulous above and beyond I will definitely recommend this jewelry store to everyone

Blue Marlin Jewelry has delightful staff, and is always willing to go the extra mile for you! I will definitely continue shopping for all of my Jewelry here!

We visited Blue Marlin jewelry while traveling through the keys and purchased a beautiful pearl necklace for my wife. The staff is very friendly and professional. Recently I just called the store to inquire about purchasing a matching bracelet. Ramsey was great to work with on this purchase. She made it easy to shop via text message as we live in PA. She took photos of the bracelets and sent them to me along with descriptions. The shopping process couldn’t be easier. Thanks again Ramsey. Hope to see you next time we’re traveling through the keys.

Beautiful selection of fine and hand crafted jewelry presented by courteous, knowledgeable and no pressure hosts—you must be at THE Blue Marlin Jewelry store in Islamorada. Add a piece to your collection at each Keys’ visit!

Blue Marlin is our favorite jewelry store - on the keys or off! They have an awesome selection of fine and unique jewelry, and the staff are wonderful!

I must first explain that I am not from the Florida Keys area. I was only lucky enough to stumble upon Blue Marlin Jewelry last winter while vacationing there. I have to say the staff and jeweler that works at this place of business are the most reputable, helpful, kind, and delightful beings I have ever met. I was flying out the next day when I first came to their store and I wanted to pick something special for my daughter. The chain had to be shortened and the jeweler completed the job within an hour or so. Since then, I have been virtual shopping with them which has been quite an experience! I phone the ladies down there and explain what I am searching for and then we have a facetime call for me to shop their fine counters of stunning jewelry. This business is the real deal and goes over the top for their customers! This gem in the keys is “A MUST SHOP! ” Thanks again, you are all so wonderful! - Jackie Peterson

Professional and knowledgeable staff. Wide variety of high quality jewelry with modern pieces, classic designs, and many beachy momentos highlighting styles reflective of Islamorada and the Florida Keys. Expert repairs too!

Blue Marlin has very beautiful and extensive jewelry collection and a very helpful, efficient and kind sales team.
It is a pleasure to work with them.

I’ve been going to Blue Marlin Jewelers every time I go to the keys- I have purchased a few really unique, beautiful pieces that are great quality. I did have a small problem with one piece and Blue Marlin helped me with every step of the process to fix it correctly. I would highly recommend them for a special piece you may be looking for.

The jewelry was just beautiful and the service was great. Highly recommend Blue Marlin Jewelry as a stop when you are in the area.

Best Jewelry store I’ve been and had the pleasure to shop at. The staff actually care about their customers. All of the jewelry is top notch and very well presented. You can tell that the owner is passionate about his store because how pristine the store is. I went there to buy my engagement ring. Honestly best decision I’ve ever made! I wouldn’t go to any other jewelry store except this one, they truly have your best interest at heart. Thank you Susan & Armando for the amazing experience and care you showed me.

Always a pleasure.beautiful jewelry and a wonderful jeweler. I would give it 6 stars if I could