Gatsby's Pizza, Bonita Springs FL

We have ordered take-out twice. Both times our pizza was superb! They do not skimp on the toppings, the spices they use really enhance the flavor and the thin crust is perfect. We will continue to have Gatsby's as our go-to pizza place!

A hidden gem in Bonita, the owners Robynn and Tim are so passionate about what they do! It pours right into the food THEY prepare. Food is always consistent. Pizza is so clean and fresh. Not greasy! Great find especially with the OH connection! Best of luck to this venture!

The only thing I can think of is: WOW!

Gatsby's Pizza is phenomenal! We ordered 1 large cheese pie, one pepperoni, and a 5 veg pie. It was SO GOOD. And the staff are just as amazing as the food! This is the kind of place you can come and really enjoy yourself after a long weekend with friends and family, the whole vibe really is just great! We will be back again and again!

10 stars they squeezed our entire soccer team! The staff was so accommodating and even offered to make pizzas i advance after a game! It was great experience for the team! Not many places are so accommodating we truly appreciate you communicating with us before the event and hopefully your ears are ok after all of that squealing!

They accommodated my son’s U10 soccer team. They were great with the kids and super friendly and excited to have us. The owners seem very hospitable.

Exceeded expectations! Very delicious pizza, my party guests loved it, I was very happy and grateful for the excellent service

Delicious! The homemade cheese balls were wonderful. The crust was thin and not greasy at all!

Not only is the pizza so delicious (thin crust, but soft and crispy, the sauce was perfection, and the pepperoni/sausage, mushrooms/onions were so fresh and tasty), the inside is super cute too, even the bathroom was cool! Also, the owners are two of the sweetest, friendliest people I have ever met! I could have chatted with them for hours! I will definitely be back—highly recommended!

So so so good! I am thrilled that Bonita Springs finally has an even better Gatsbys Pizza then the previous one, that was fabulous, but this… Oh my goodness! The pretzel bites and beer cheese, so good and the Pizza, well, it doesn’t get better than this! Yummy!