Goodfellas NY Pizza (Sunrise)

Since they're merging with something called Piezoni they replaced the pizza ovens with one of the conveyer belt set ups. Pizza crust was soggy and lacked the pizza oven taste. Can get the same style pie at Sam's Club for less than half the price.

Stop by GoodFellas pizza was greeted by Emma she was GREAT! Her service was impeccable. Then we met the cook Daniel, wow the red sauce was homemade style tasted phenomenal! The dough was done to perfection! Thank you both for an enjoyable night

Just moved to the area and when it come time to order a pizza we decided to risk it to something local instead of the regular big names. Well, this pizza did not disappointed! My husband is a healthy freak that has outs delicious breads and doughs of his life long ago, but when it came to this pizza, he ate 3 slices and couldn’t stop exclaiming how delicious it was, the dough, the sauce, the fresh ingredients. One of these days we will stop to eat in but for now I’m just happy to finally have a delicious authentic pizza a call away!

The pizza was great here for years, they’ve clearly changed everything for the worse.

The crust is different, the pizza is swimming in grease, everything seems like it’s been “cheapened”, it’s all totally different. Unfortunately the pizza went from being one of the best around to one of the worst. I now drive twice as far to go to Pizza Lovers, a place that still does things the right way.

Place went downhill quickly. Used to be delicious pizza and cozy atmosphere.
Now, the food is greasy (cheese slides of the pizza like butter), the crust tastes like cardboard and hospital atmosphere after redo. They got rid of their pizza oven and changed it to a conveyer belt like Dominos. They changed the pizza to a smaller size for almost the same price and their ridiculous new phone system is the cherry on top.

Their build your own pizza is very good! We usually order a large pizza with mushrooms and fresh garlic. The fresh garlic isn't on the list with all the toppings. You will need to ask for it.
The above was written in July of 2023.
We recently ordered the same pizza we always get. However, this time, it wasn't that good. Crust was very, very thin in the center. Toppings were very light.

I’ve been coming here for years. This place must have new management my pizza was awful the crust is like cardboard and the chicken was not of good quality it was over cooked. There is no love in this food and you can taste it. Leaving 4 stars due to the great food this place offered in the past. Fix it or you’ll drive all the original customer away.

Excellent experience for a dine-in. Shame I never got take pictures. But maybe next time, I'll remember. I'd like to give a shout out that waitress who helped out with our table. Wishing you the best of luck. L'Chaim from the Garcias.

Place must be under new management. Its not as cozy a restaurant as it was. Bright white walls screams cheap. The pizza was like cardboard, overcooked and the sauce is sour. Too bad. This use to be a pretty good place but like all places once they get under new management they go cheap with product, expensive with price and eventually a 1 star rating like all the other pizza places in Sunrise.

Very clean. Service is excellent! The food was so delicious and fresh! A definite go to spit!

Went down hill this was my favorite place I blogged about it but I guess they sold it and it’s just not the same will not return I need to find another fav place of pizza. I seen the. Take things out of fridge re heat add sauce just not the same.

There's no or place too comparison, everyday the Freshes ingredient's, and the meal's are cooled to Perfection Mowaaa

Just ordered a chicken parmigiana from good fellas.
The chicken is over cooked and very bland.
The pasta is decent but not the greatest.
The garlic rolls are really doughy and tasteless.
Overall they do not put love into making the food.

The pizza was average not gonna lie, the crust was doughy and thick, not much flavor in the sauce

Service is trash they gave me the wrong cover food wasn’t ready even though I called in the person answering the phone didn’t speak English and they forgot to put the meatballs in the order disappointed food is spilling in the bag trash!

This has been our go to pizza pick up spot for years. During the pandemic they were great and working hard. Now, post pandemic, I’ve had 3 bad experiences in a row. It seems like it’s all young people working there and they have no sense of urgency and seem to be very overwhelmed. They cannot handle the influx of to go orders and customers in the restaurant. While I was waiting for my to go order, which was ready forever before they handed it to me, I was observing customers at the tables who were waiting for service. It was uncomfortable to say the least. Also, recently we actually did dine in with our family and did not have a good experience. 3 bad experiences in a row and unfortunately I’m out. If you’re out in Plantation, I recommend Jacaranda Pizza.

Placed an order over the phone. Went to pick it up and they had given my pizzas to someone else! And I wasn't the only customer there experiencing this.

The attention is TERRIBLE. The young man named Gaspar attended to us. I don't take our things on time, I take the tickets we requested at the end of the meal. I requested some spoons and I never bring them. THIS PLACE IS HORRIBLE.