Goodfella's Pizza, Vero Beach FL

Who can do a bunch of pizza ready by 5 pm, GoodFella’s. Pizza is so great. Vero warm welcome is amazing. It feels like small town again.

I brought my wife here. Not fancy but we needed a pizza fix. This is the biggest pizza pie I’ve ever seen. The pizza guy checked on us several times; it was quaint & friendly. There is a place to sit outside and I like that on these spring days. Our food was goooood and they brought out pies separately instead of waiting for them both to be ready. Honestly there was no room to put these pizzas on the table.

I was looking for pizza late night after the gym and this was the only place open. You know if the pizza's going to be good when you see the slices and I was scared. The gentleman who served me was very nice and polite but the pizza slice reminded me of my elementary school lunchroom pizza. I haven't thought of that disgusting excuse for good pizza in decades. I won't be back.

I’ve never been served a pizza so hot and droopy. Whoever put it in the oven must have gotten lazy and forgot it there. The first bite burnt my lip, tongue, and roof of my mouth so bad they started swelling. 5/10. Good seasoning, bad construction and cheese/sauce ratio.

We usually go to the store in fort Pierce, but just moved to Vero, and decided to try the local store.
We ordered a Sicilian with bacon and ham.
Crust was burnt, but not too bad. Pizza was not very warm, which is very odd for just coming out of the oven and only taking 10 minutes to deliver.
It could have used more cheese and a few more minutes in the oven.
You can tell the delivery driver had something heavy on top of our box. The middle of the pizza was missing it's toppings and cheese, with a mess on the lid of the box.
I'm torn on this experience. Definitely not a normal Goodfellas experience, that we are used to.
We will definitely try the store again, but probably without using the delivery service.
Would love to add the picture, but I don't see the option.
I will keep you updated
Pizza was around $28
Fees and delivery tip added around $15, more dollars

Terrible, no service and they only have paper plates so disappointed.
We used to enjoy it there.

This has happen twice within a month, delivery in 40 to hour. Came hour and 40 minutes. Delivery guy backed me up. Tonight it was hour and 30 minutes. I asked for a adjusted bill and she said i dont think we can, so i said DONT DELIVER IT THEN! IM DONE WITH THAT PLACE!

Good food but experience was bad. Food served on paper plates, no plates for wings, small napkins, and no servers to serve us. Didn't like the over counter ordering.

Definitely the best Steak Stromboli I've had in a long time! Just wish it came with more marinara. Highly recommend it.

First time at this location. Good food and friendly staff. Will be back. Update, have been back and few times, consistent and good!

Amazing food, service, and place! I love how many options they offer, and each option is delicious. Highly recommend checking this place out!

Always on time always good portion always done correctly I order 2 xs a week at least. NEVER DISSATISFIED OR DISAPPOINTED?

Order at the counter, very simple, they do serve you when the food is ready. Eggplant Parmesan sliced thin and fried crispy and very good, Greek salad fresh and excellent! Will definitely be returning

First and last time here. I called and ordered " charred pizza" which shows a picture on the Vero site and they didn't know what I was talking about when it shows it in their menu pictures. They were rude on the phone never go back.

Awful pizza, but even more awful service. Rude, rude beyond rude. Don't bother, so many better places to choose from.

So glad Goodfellas is finally in Vero. Always hear how good they are. Well, it's true! The food is fresh and well prepared. Will absolutely order there again. Welcome to Vero!

I tried the stuffed pizza.it was worth the experience.one stuffed pizza was plenty for 4 adults.we will definitely be ordering this again