Goodfella's Pizza, Port St. Lucie FL

Amazing staff great tasting pizza, friendly environment and most importantly very clean restaurant!

I order every week from this restaurant.
I have had to place an order for catering as well.
No other place compares with Goodfellows in St Lucie West.
Anthony is always happy to see me. You know the food is good when the place is crowded.
His gravy is so delicious, no agada.
Eggplant parm is my favorite, thin spaghetti, salad with house dressing and garlic knots. Everything is always fresh.
Give this place a try you wont be disappointed.
They deliver too!

Excellent food and family friendly atmosphere. All the food they brought to your table with a smile, even the slices of pizza.

This place sucks ……ordered a two slice special “TO GO” cashier made it a point to let me know I can add a tip on a to go order. When I skipped the tip during checkout the cashier let pay with my credit card first then informed me they were all of a sudden out of cheese pizza. That’s so grimy and low down never coming back.

My sister went to pick up a couple of slices the other day they were clearly in the display case way to long it was awful. The pizza was old

I ordered at 10: 23 this morning and was told it would be delivered by 11. It’s now 11: 43 and it still hasn’t been delivered. Called and they said it should be delivered soon? ! This is my first time trying them as everyone has referred them but I haven’t even gotten my pizza yet and that alone will keep me from ordering from them again! Ordered from the California Blvd location in Port St Lucie Fl.

Edit: It’s now 12: 30 (over 2 hrs after ordering)! And pizza is still not here.called again and same guy answered. I asked for the manager which he replied was speaking.told him this was unacceptable and he said he’s taking half the price off. He said they got busy and he apologized. I called right after they opened and if they were busy that early then he should have told me they were backed up and shouldn’t have told me it would be here at 11! This is rediculous!

Edit: Just called again and same guy (says he’s the manager) said he’s Still not there? ! No, no he’s not! Told him I was writing a review as this is insane and he said whatever I’m just canceling it then and then he hung up on me! Unacceptable! Do not order from this place!

We have only ordered the Grandma pie and it’s excellent. One time it was a little oily. I told them this time about it (and they was very nice about it) and they made it perfect!

Ordered delivery came late and cold. Do not shop at this Pizza place. Also tasted disgusting.

We order from them at least once a week. Best tasting takeout in PSL. Felt like our dinner tonight was made out of love and delivered with love too. Thank you.

Called Sunday Dec 4 and got cut off. Called and same fella answered the phone but didn’t seem too happy. After a question about their Roman Pizza he hung up. Called back and had some more questions on cost of the pizza and cost for additional toppings (2.50 and up he said) trying to finish my order he hung up again. I called back in disbelief and asked if he just deliberately hung up on me. He said sorry “I’m just having a bad day, it’s really super busy in here. So I proceeded to order 2 extra veggy toppings and he gave me the price of $14.99. The final cost was $28 plus change so of course I had to asked “HOW much were the 2 toppings? And he hung up again. Well by that time I could not let it slide so I called back and their answering service told me they are not accepting calls from this number? ! I managed to get thru after a couple more attempts and the same guy answered. I immediately asked if he was the manager before asking to speak to the manager and he said he was the manager. I sure hope the REAL manager reads this because if he indeed is the real manager then being super busy for him is a bad thing? ! Needless to say I’m still in disbelief after I told him “no problem then if your just too busy…I’ll be ordering elsewhere from now on”. Real bad!

My favorite location for goodfellas pizza wings and pizza are always fresh and pretty chill atmosphere, always a good time when stop in for dine in or take out they have a really good lunch special great salads and baked ziti and nice sizes slices and pizza good pizza

Order calzone with no ricotta, they add more ricotta and bread than mozzarella cheese, called back and the guy told me that a calzone without ricotta is not a calzone. Thank you for your customer service. You just lose another customer