HOLEY MOLEY BAGEL BAR NYC, Orange Park FL

My Dad and I love this place. Best #NYBagels anywhere. Stop by, you won't be disappointed.

Quiet, quaint and very accommodating. Military friendly. Wasn’t in love with the omelette or breakfast potatoes but would like to return and try out the bagels. The omelette I felt was not cooked as much as I would prefer inside. The cheese was thick inside and not mixed well within. The potatoes were overly seasoned and very salty. However, I would still return to try some bagels.

I’ve been looking forward to trying bagels from here and have heard great things. Unfortunately, me and my boyfriend have tried to come to this place two different times, one time at 12: 30 on a Saturday, and at 1pm on a Tuesday and both times they have been closed. You guys need to update your hours or else don’t display that you are open until 2pm when clearly you aren’t.

I've been here ONE TIME. I drove from Green Cove Springs specifically to order a bagel with lox. I expected a good experience because of reviews I read. I didn't eat inside so can't speak about the atmosphere. What I will say is, I ate one bite only to find a approximately 1" piece of LATEX GLOVE (FINGER) in my food! I had NO DESIRE TO EAT ANYTHING ELSE from Holy Moly! I am still so disgusted and it's been over a year since this happened! I think it's pretty clear that careless food prep is to blame and I wasn't about to ask for " seconds ". No blood and no finger appeared to be in my bagel but I truly believe the individual who left the glove in my bagel either didn't care or rushed, putting me (I'm immune compromised) and God only knows how many others at high risk of disease or a choking incident (or death. Why not report immediately? 1. I was about to hurl and decided someone was already aware that a finger was missing off the glove. They knew what they did. I believe that but in retrospect I should have gone in gagging and reported the incident immediately. I wish I had. I think a classy, real bagel shop in Clay County would be great. Haven't been able to eat bagels publicly since though and you can bet your sweet (blank!) I check my food before I eat out!

If you live in orange park Florida and have not been into this bagel shop- you aren’t doing life right! Soooooo good and the owner is incredibly nice! Just do yourself a favor and stop in- you won’t regret it!

This place gets 5 stars all around! The first time I tried it she was busy and was the only one working. Super friendly, didn’t feel rushed and got our items fast and hot. So delicious.
Went back again today, guy in the front was just as nice. Food was delicious again. I’ve been recommending to all my friends and co-workers. No pictures, because I just wanted to eat it.

I am from New York so having a place like this in Jacksonville is awesome. So far great quick service and the Baoneggandcheese sandwiches (it’s one word for us NYers) remind me of home

I've passed this place many times and have always said I'd go. I went in today and got a deebo (steak, egg, peppers, and gouda) on a jalapeño asaiago bagel. It was better than I thought it would be. The home fries were hot and well seasoned.
Kelly took my order and made it. She provided excellent service and food.
Don't miss out on these bagels!

Hours state open until 1pm on Sundays. Arrived at 12: 36 and was refused food. False advertisement! Close at 12: 30 if that’s the case!

This was my second time trying this location and the food was absolutely delicious. The vibe of the restaurant is also great. And idk what they season them home made fries with but they are so good. I will be a returning customer

Oh my is all I can say! Not only is the staff amazing, it’s really hard to drive home smelling the delicious goodness in the seat next to me! Everything is so fresh and made with love! Soooo delicious!

Holy sign is down. Seems to be new people. No milk, creamer not on ice. Tasted like packaged bagels not fresh.

Sadly the ONLY day we ever want to/can go is on Mondays:/ but I wish we could enjoy it again

Just left

Ate it too fast so no picture but customer service and food was top tier

The man who took my order and made my food took good care of us

We will be back over and over again.

I really love the bagel choices in this little spot. I used to buy a dozen on the weekends and the haul would last us through most of the week for a quick breakfast before work. Now they only sell the bagels at the individual price point.
Even though we love the varieties they offer, we will probably just stick with store bought and season them ourselves.

I made a trip to Holey Moley while I was in the Jacksonville area, and I was not disappointed. I ordered a sausage, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel. The sausage was hot and tasty, and the egg was real. The bagel itself was much better than the bagel I recently had at Panera. I'm glad I gave Holey Moley a try.

The first time I visited, I enjoyed my food. The bagels are really good as well as everything on their menu. However, the service on my next visit was aweful. The staff were not at all organized.