Jersey Brothers Pizza & Pasta, Bradenton FL

The food used to be outstanding! I recommended it to everyone. But new management took over and it’s not even close now. Hope they get it together. Def not a busy as before

Friendly staff. The pizza is just not my taste. Maybe not warm enough with the website stating much longer time than the pizza being ready. You do get email notification, but plan for less time.

Best NY style pizza in the area. I've tried all the others. It's not even up for debate that this is the best tasting!

Pizza was 2 hours old and and lady refused to make a new pepperoni pizza fresh to put in shelf. They do have good pizza but customer service was horrendous! Come on people that’s your job job job! Get with the program

Pizza was excellent! The baked ziti, on the other hand, was not…hardly any sauce, mostly cheese and pasta…threw it away. Tried to message the restaurant, no response

Best pizza I've had in Florida. By far. I'm from Queens. Ate pizza all over NYC/ NJ, and lived here in FL for 17 years. West Palm, now Bradenton. This is real sauce. Real mozzarella. No straight out of the can marinara, and Dollar General cheese. Great crust. I HIGHLY recommend Jersey Brothers. These guys are good. Real good. Just got done stuffing my face, and I look like the blueberry girl from Willy Wonka. Eat here. You will not be disapointed.

Perfect pizza. Thin crust was not overcooked. Toppings just right.
Returning soon for sure!

Ordered the Lasagna Pizza online yesterday and it was one of the best pizzas that I have had in a very long time. Normally stick to the pepperoni, mushroom, sausage, meatball usuals (which have always been very good). Saw the Lasagna Pizza on the online menu and had to try. They knocked it out of the park. Plenty of sauce, cheese, and meatballs, plus ricotta. It was like being back in NYC again.

We used to get amazing pizza here and had not been in several months. Last night picked up what o imagined was going to be an amazing pizza as we had always picked up! I never looked until getting home! What happened! Where were the toppings? It was a sad pathetic pizza that didn’t even taste the same! Not impressed and will not go back ‘ so whatever changed over the past few months please fix it! The pizza used to me amazing! Now I’d say the freezer grocery store pizza is a better option!

Pro tip. Dont order any of their grilled chicken subs or salads. You basically get chicken jerky. Ultra dry and waaaay overcooked. Took me five minutes to chew a bite enough to swallow. Total waste of money. I usually have a great experience here. Either its the night cook or they just suck at cooking grilled chicken. Welp, i guess its peanut butter and jelly for me tonight. Everything else was good as always.

The pizza was great, and the young lady that took my order was super friendly. It would have been nice to have a little background music.

Strip mall NY slice spot, right off I75 exit 217 in Bradenton. No fuss, authentic NY slices. We stopped my for lunch on way home to Gainesville from Naples and really enjoyed!

Not a lot of good pizza shops in FL but this place sure does have real good pizza. It’s more of a take out place not a dine in restaurant. Probably some of the best pizza I’ve had in FL, around the Bradenton area

We went to Jersey Brothers Pizza for the first time and it was excellent. The pizza was perfect and the garlic knots were the bomb. We highly recommend Jersey Brothers if you want good authentic pizza.

I usually enjoy their pasta dinners take out but I ordered online through their website tonight, picked up our food and when I got home there was hardly any sauce on our pasta meals. It was so little sauce that we had to open a can of our own pasta sauce to add to it. Also the food containers were not sealed all the way when we picked up the food and it ended up creating a huge mess in the car from all the excess water from the pasta. I tried calling to complain about our food but the phone number doesn’t work. It might have had something to do with the fact that their internet was down at the restaurant and they were only accepting cash for walk-in orders. It was such an unpleasant experience that we’ll be looking for a different Italian restaurant to order from in the future.

The food is always fresh & delicious. I’ve never been disappointed. Their Sicilian Pie is always light & fluffy. White pie with xtra garlic is too yummy for words & if you like chicken, bacon Ranch then theirs is a must.
Queens, NY Italian Mama

Best garlic knots, best cannoli, super delicious meatballs & caprese salad- will be back for pizza night & wings in the future. Wish I could a 6th star out of 5. Nice, new management!

This local spot is serving up some pretty good pie and garlic knots! The crust was cooked perfectly with ample toppings. Yhe only complaint would be it was a little greesy, but I did order extra pepperoni and bacon.