Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream, Winter Park FL

It was ok. Expensive but all cones these days are. The ice cream was good but odd flavors and I was hoping for more standard flavors. I'm sure that kids would love the flavors including the ice cream infused with fruity pebbles.

I wish I could have met kelly and take in a picture with her. This was one of the best strawberry ice creams i've ever had. And the young server that was here on Saturday 8/12 was very friendly and gave us all the samples we wanted.

The Mexican hot chocolate is one of the best ice creams we’ve had. I also loved the Oreo-dough, if you’re a cookie lover this is the one to get. They give great portions as well!

My wife got a mixed pint of key lime pie and oat meal cream pie and she thought it was just okay. We have had plenty of other flavors from other stores and they were terrific. I'm not sure what made this visit kind of a miss.

The ice cream was delicious and the young man serving us was friendly and professional! Highly recommend!

I was surprised to see that I was charged an extra $1.50 for my sorbet since it’s non dairy. I’ve never experienced an up charge at an ice cream place for getting non dairy ice cream flavor, especially not sorbet since most ice cream shops carry sorbet.
Maybe they figured since coffee shops do this, they can too?
Otherwise a good experience with good service, but I don’t think I’d jump at the chance to return since there are other places with non dairy options and no up charge.
If you don’t have a dietary restriction this place is pretty good.

Best Ice-cream in town! They have several locations and we tried all of them they have an amazing flavors

Kelly’s is the best! The ice cream is not store bought like other places. The flavors are different and good. My favorite is the gram cracker ice cream.

My 2¢. Stopped into a Kelly’s & ordered 2 different flavors today. For a homemade ice-cream, it’s just okay. Keep experimenting, because your own recipes aren’t quite perfected yet Kelly S. Remember, there is always room for improvement.
Best luck.

Delicious ice cream and sorbet. I can’t wait to try different flavors and treats on subsequent vidits. This location is very small, in a tiny marketplace. Take out or eat outside only

Penelope was amazing and took great care of me and my mom on her first kellys visit! They always have the best ice cream here, 10/10 recommend

Whats great about Sunday at Kelly's? Only one employee on a Sunday with a line out the door and no milk for milkshakes. Good thing this is so expensive.

Stopped by just before closing. The Toasted Coconut is probably the best ice cream I have ever tasted. Just great.