Key Lime Pie Bakery, Key West FL
| Address | 412 Greene St, Key West, FL | ||||||||||||||
| Phone | (305) 296-9515 | ||||||||||||||
| Hours |
|
||||||||||||||
| Website | keylimepiebakery.com | ||||||||||||||
| Categories | Pie Shop, Coffee Shop, Gift Shop, Ice Cream Shop | ||||||||||||||
| Rating | 4.3 15 reviews | ||||||||||||||
|
Similar companies nearby Strachan's Ice Cream & Desserts - Palm Harbor — 105 US-19 ALT, Palm Harbor, FL, United States Mixed Fillings Pie Shop — 1049 Park St, Jacksonville, FL The Kookaburra Downtown — 24 Cathedral Pl, St. Augustine, FL, United States Village Inn — 4571 13th St, St Cloud, FL |
Key Lime Pie Bakery reviews
15Honestly was disappointed, they only had frozen ones ready which we purchased and thawed out. Wasn't really that great but maybe it's because it was frozen.
One of the best key lime pie you will find around Key west.highly recommended. If you love ice cream, try the Cuban coffee flavor.amazing!
So far my favorite key lime pie. Limey and not so sweet. Nice location and cute souvenirs. Parking took some time to find.
The BEST Key Lime pie i ever had. We had the coconut key lime pie. I was just a little sad they dont ship pies. We wanted to ship some pie to my dad.
The women who took my order was so nice, she told me the story how the store is now owed and operated by all the employees that work there. They have a great gift shop as well. This is a place you have to visit when in key west. You will not be disappointed.
We loved the creative shop and the pie was absolutely AMAZING! The pumpkin spice latte ice cream had an excellent flavor and texture! The owner was incredibly nice and gave us a bunch of awesome history facts about Key West. THANK YOU!
The place was practically deserted, we were the only people there and went because we saw it on The Profit. I was really disappointed in the "famous" key lime pie which was basically frozen and a lot more like ice cream than pie which I didn't enjoy at all. It's more of a Sweet Pete's candy shop than it is a key lime pie store.
They carry a good variety of key lime products. We were able to purchase products here from Peppers of Key West. They also have coffees here.
The best key lime pie in the Keys and I've tried most of all. It's worth the wait to get to one of their several locations. This location allows you to test taste assorted key lime cookies, too!
Key lime pie by-the-slice is soooo good here! I also got some souvenirs and a couple of the rum soaked coconut cakes; staff was very friendly and helpful
The key lime pie is great. Believe me I've made it a life long mission to try this amazing mix of flavors everywhere I can. Tart with a sweet crunchy crust. If they put key limes in it then this store sells it.
I'm not a big pie connoisseur but both my wife and I found it to be inedible tonite. It literally tasted like tin. Oh well. Maybe they just had a bad batch.
Had a girls day trip down to the Keys and had to stop here for the best pie! Adorable place inside and out. I tried the coconut keylime pie and original keylime. Both are to die for! Couldnt have asked for anything better than to eat amazing pie with my best friend watching roosters cross the street
The mans and I are on the hunt for our favorite key lime pie in Key West.
This place was on a listical so we obliged.
We had three categories to rate and our scores are as follows:
Sweetness: 5/10
Tartness: 7/10
Crust: 5/10
This was my favorite, as I liked the amount of tartness it had. The other two pies we tried were much more sweet and less tart. Kermit’s was hubs’ favorite so far.
Key lime pies are tasty and it makes for a great resting spot while walking downtown.
Seating (table and chairs) is limited.
I wanted to try it after I watched the show on the profit!
I loved the pie dipped in chocolate but not the regular pie!
Staff are very friendly!