Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar, Islamorada FL

Went for drinks and apps by the water, and will return to see the sharks swimming by. Great spot!

Beautiful spot in the keys. Out by the water. Live band, food, weather was nice. Staffwas fun to hang out with food was great.

Absolutely beautiful place great people! Bartender on her game!
Huge shout out to Sarah/Karen ️️️️

Food was excellent and large portions. Drinks were very inexpensive for the area. Went around sunset so it was very crowded.service was a bit slow but our server Derrick was attentive and did his best to make sure we were happy. Live entertainment was very good. Overall great experience.

Just had drinks and appetizers on a rainy day. Great hostest, servers, waterfront still peaceful in the rain. Liked the local beer and pretzel sticks, crab chowder excellent perfect to warm up from the rain.

Hard to get staff to seat our party of four. Many tables had only one person drinking a beer and taking up the whole table. Bad, and rude management.

Amazing! Best place to take your fresh catch and have them cook it! Fantastic live music and the best sunsets!

Lorelei is one of our favorite spots for watching the beautiful sunsets of the Keys. Lots of fun bartenders, great live music, and delicious food. We love Sunday School on Sunday mornings, which offers a great breakfast menu along with $3 mimosas, bloodmarys, or screwdrivers!

Fantastic spot right on the water. Service was amazing Food was delicious. The fish sandwich was the best I've ever had. The perfect spot for a nice lunch. We will absolutely be back next time we are in town. The frozen key lime pie was also a treat. Tasted like ice cream! Yum!

Don’t come here with a big group! First the food was not that great! Our waitress was horrible and wouldn’t split the checks with a party of 13 even though we told her ahead of time! There was a few waiters we watched that was on top of it, but not ours unfortunately.

We’ve been going to the Lorelei for a few decades. Although it used to be one of Islamorada‘s best kept secrets it’s now a busy happening hotspot. There’s always live entertainment in the form of music for everyone and sometimes magic shows for kids but the adults enjoy them also. The candy cane has always been there frozen signature drink for many years! Their food is delicious, service is spectacular and sunsets are stunning! Various seating areas offer something for everyone! Arrive early even on weeknights if you don’t want to wait in line to be seated!

They use too much plastic, mediocre food and the music is too loud. The waitress was really sweet tho.

Great breakfast. Awesome service from Mendi. I’m so blessed to live in the Keys. Lorelei’s is a local treasure.

The atmosphere here is great! This is literally one of the best restaurants to go to when the weather is nice. There is a constant sea breeze that keeps you cool and refreshed.

We came to see brothers of others play, but we have been here before. Service is normally good but they (like everyone else) are short staffed. We had to wait 40m for a waitress, however once we did have one; everything went quickly and smoothly.
All the food was very good, and the price is reasonable considering this is a beachside restaurant.
I hope they can get more staff in the future for busy nights when they have live music. My previous experiences were good so I am going to give them the benefit of the doubt for the sake of this review.

Will be back there next month to see the same band play again!

This place was so fun! Great choice of seating from closer to the bar to on the back with live music. All staff was friendly and helpful and the key lime pie was delicious. Highly recommend!

Food and staff is great. Views are amazing. We had lunch there and you could choose your table. Went back a few days later to have dinner and watch the sunset and they were slammed. 1.5 hr wait.