Mixed Fillings Pie Shop, Jacksonville FL

This is one of the few shops in 5 points that really cares about the costumer. Great food and great people. Just try it out and see what I'm talking about. Thanks to all the employees.

Creme Brulee pie was amazing. Great ambiance and friendly staff. Such a great addition to 5 Points area of Jax! We got there around 2pm and they were selling out of various flavors at that time. Probably good to go earlier in the day of possible.

This is a GREAT pie place! I recommend the key lime pie, it is delicious! The crust is a gram cracker pretzel crust and it is so good. They have amazing pies, you always get them on time, and the people are so friendly. If you are looking for a pie shop, you should go check out Mixed Fillings Pie Shop!

Had a delightful experience at Mixed Fillings Pie Shop in Five Points, Jacksonville, FL. The Key Lime Pie and Apple Pie were standout highlights—also, every name is a great pie pun, adding a fun touch. The staff curate a friendly and welcoming atmosphere. Highly recommend it for pie or baked goods enthusiasts. The variety of pies and the creativity in naming them make for an enjoyable visit. Whether you're into classic flavors or unique combinations, Mixed Fillings Pie Shop has something for every palate.

Never been here. I called, they would not assist me with purchase of gift card by phone. I live out of town & wanted to surprise my sis n law w the gift card. She had been wanted to go here.

Absolutely love this place. The pies are amazing! I recommend the key lime and maple chess pies.

During a recent trip to attend a national dog competition with my friends, we discovered Mixing Fillings, a bakery that soon became the highlight of our visit. We were there to celebrate my friend’s success in reaching the finals, and we wanted something special. The customer service at Mixing Fillings was nothing short of outstanding. The gentleman who assisted us was incredibly attentive, listening to our story and helping us choose the perfect celebratory treat.

We decided on the peanut butter pie, and it was an absolute revelation. The pie was the epitome of sweet, decadent indulgence. The peanut butter flavor was rich and pronounced, perfectly complemented by a delicious candy bottom that took the whole experience to another level. It’s easy to see why ‘Mixing Fillings’ is so well-regarded - their pies are a culinary delight.

The atmosphere at Mixing Fillings is as delightful as their desserts - cozy, inviting, and perfect for any occasion.

Mixing Fillings is a must-visit. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and treat yourself to one of their incredible pies.

I wholeheartedly recommend the peanut butter pie - it’s a game-changer. Mixing Fillings isn’t just a bakery; it’s an experience that brings joy and deliciousness to every bite. Everyone should give their fun pies a try! I will be back next year for agility nationals 2024!

The best pie in Florida we found at
Mixed Fillings Pie in Five Points - Jacksonville.preciousness in the flavors and presentation of the pies.
Congratulations to the owner Natasha Burton, efficient, friendly and pleasant person.
Success. Success. Success.
Deservedly. Thank you very much

You haven't eaten pie until you've had a Mixed Fillings pie! Chef Natasha was so kind and went out of her way to help our company lunch stay on schedule. Delicious every time and a wonderful business to support!

We experienced Mixed Fillings Pie Shop for our first time and we were excited just looking at the pies in their cases. This is a female owned family business that makes some tasty pies with creative recipes. Today we ordered three slices and they were: Beach Don’t Kill My Vibe (coconut cream with a chocolate ganache topping, whipped cream and flaky crust) and Chill Don’t Cross the Lime (Spiced Cranberry sauce, lime custard, whipped cream, pretzel brown sugar crust) and lastly, OK Boomer (Old Fashioned toasted pecan crust is filled with decadent French silk and topped with an espresso whipped cream).
Slices are around $7 and whole pies are $40. They even offer a pie flight which is several slices of pie that make up a whole pie for $40.
The pies we tried are magnificent and well worth not only the price but worth a three hour drive from Orlando to experience this exceptional emporium of super tasty pie heaven. The staff member that assisted us is a cousin of the owner and she was awesome, friendly and very helpful. We have many more pies to try so a future visit is planned. We might even order pies for Christmas. If you plan to order pies fir the holidays you really should think about that weeks before the holidays.

Impossible to go wrong here - everything is delicious! That being said, my favorites are the key lime with pretzel crust (Blurred Limes), banana crème with peanut butter crust (Brand New Day’O) and the quiche with bacon (honestly one of the best things I’ve ever eaten).

Great people, great pies, super fast delivery and friendly service. I’ll be a returning customer!

Owned an operated by a women that recognizes her staffs talents as well as a powerful intelligent voice in the community. The pie is worthy of many more awards, but even if it was not good I would still spend my money here based on how she conducts herself as an employer and person in the community. The key pie is worth selling a kidney for.

Love Mixed Fillings pie selection! My favorite is the Key Lime pie but everything I’ve had has been great. I love that they have a pie flight! I’ve been able to try so many flavors.