PEPPERONI'S PIZZERIA, High Springs FL

The pizza is better than your typical big brand pizza delivery places. Their pasta was pretty good, and the bread was good. The guy behind the counter seemed a bit lost, and when I asked him everything was there, he second guessed himself and circled the kitchen twice.fortunately, everything was there.

I'm sorry I didn't get names. On Friday June 2, I walked in, placed my order for my family. It was deleted or cancelled may I say on accident. I understood things happen when stress sets in. Being a caretaker I understand. So a mistake was done but the owner or the manager fixed it and made it right and I couldn't be more thankful and grateful for this amazing group of 2 people that helped my family and I enjoy a meal without a fuss and we are grateful. Amazing people, amazing neighborhood Pizzeria. Thank you for making our night that much more to enjoy? By the way the calzones were to die for we enjoyed every bit️

Ordered through the phone, the employee was kind and took my order quickly! She said it would be 15 minutes, and it was right on time.service was fast and friendly and the food is amazing!

Pepperoni's always does a great job having my order ready on time and always gets it right. I use their online ordering system and have never had any issues. Food is always good!

Hadn't gone here in awhile because we moved but just got a large thin crust no toppings, just cheese and sauce. Very burnt and the crust was super tough. I'm so disappointed. This was going to be my Sunday treat. On top of that the service was lousy. I had to check that the guy behind the counter had a pulse because he sure doesn't have a smile. So sad that things have changed. I'm hoping mine was a unique experience.

The service is always friendly but the quality has gone downhill. When I first moved here I couldn’t believe how great the pizzas were. Among the best I’d tasted and I’m definitely a pizza connoisseur. Then they changed the sauce and afterward it all went downhill. I still stop by every once in a while but last few times have been disappointing and after today, I won’t order again. About the same as Hungry Howie’s now. The smell was so bad when I opened the box today, it took my appetite away. What happened?

Great little blue collar pizza place. Limited seating but that's not a downside unless you plan on dining in during lunch rush. Definitely worth a visit.

I stopped here as I was visiting some family, and there was not many options for food. I went in and had 2 lunch specials - 2 slices and a drink. The drink machine is in very bad condition - it had obvious signs of standing water and appeared to have not been cleaned in some time. The pizza I didn't know about until we got into the car, but it was bad. It was definitely old, and had been sitting out. The sauce had developed a "crust" from loosing it's moisture. I took one bite and knew I couldn't eat it. So both my wife and I threw it away. I don't know if this is custom or because it was close to the end of lunch, but it was not edible. I will definitely cross this one off the list to eat at when I come out there. I hope you guys see this and make some changes to how you guys keep and store the pizza.

Facility has always been clean (the few times I’ve been in) and staff has been friendly but professional. Pizza is fantastic!

After 20 years of great pizza seems they have changed their formula. The crust is now thin and tasteless. Too bad too because this was the best pizza within 20 miles.
Update: Seems like it was a one off bad. The next pizza I got was awesome!

Traveling thru and stopped in. The manager was awesome and the pizza was really good. Great price, awesome service! What else can you ask for?

Honestly some of the best pizza (to my taste) I've had. Crispy crust, sauce up to the crust, vegetables under the cheese and nice flavored pepperoni.not the hormel or bland ones you get at a chain.

Not from the area but if I was in within 30 mins of this place I would detour for it.

Wow…. Just plain wow. We passed this place whilst exploring out here in the farm lands and decided to drop on by for lunch and boy oh boy am I glad we did! They were so delicious, quality north style pizza. I was blown away as it’s always hard finding good pizza in the south, Florida specifically. We each had a slice of pizza as well as some pepperoni rolls. Everything was to die for and I wish I’d snapped some photos. We will probably go back later today though and I’ll make sure to take some pics. Do yourself a favour and try this place out! You will not regret it!

My husband and I ordered a large pizza there which turned out to be very good however two of the five items that we attempted to get on the pizza were not on there. When I got home and realized that the pizza was not correct I called the pizzeria the young gentleman DJ was so polite and so kind and very respectful. I can't say the same for Holly the manager though. Not only did she not want to hear what I had to say about the pizza, when she got on the phone she never said that she was the manager just her name not how can I help you is there anyway I can make this correct or right for you. None of it. Not only was she rude but she hung up on me. Then when I called back she refused to get on the phone with me and that's how I got DJ who did an excellent job at customer service. If I knew of a way that I could get a hold of Joel and Karen Mills who are the owners of the pizzeria I would love for them to know that DJ deserves a very big pat on the back possibly an increase in pay and Holly does not deserve the job as the manager there. It's a real shame very disappointing my family has always ordered from pepperonis and really enjoy it.due to this experience we probably will not be back. If anyone has any information about Joel and Karen Mills who own the pizzeria I would love for someone to contact me or send information through my profile to get in touch with them. What a shame the place is rated as one of the best places to eat pizza in high springs. Very disappointed in Holly.

Their pizza was great. Service was top notch. A slice above the rest. For such a small place they sure made a big impression.

First time eating here, a bit pricey but it was delicious! Pizza was cooked accordingly, the breadsticks were AMAZING and so is their marinara sauce. Love it and will be back!

I really like this place. The personal cheese pizza is perfect. I get garlic knots as well but lately they have been skipping the butter on top and they aren't nearly as tasty without it.

Best Pizza in Alachua county. Great crust, incredible sauce. On busy Saturday nights expect orders to take 40 minutes, it’s worth the wait…it’s that good…

Used to be a great place to get food now they’re pizza quality has taken a serious dive. Won’t be back again. Doesn’t help that they have children running the store complete disorganized disaster.

Very friendly service and nice staff but my order was wrong. Got a credit which was nice but would have loved my order to have been right.