Pizzeria Della Nonna, Sarasota FL

Been to this place over the years, and things were usually ok in terms of the food. But recently, I picked up some pizza and after eating had very bad stomach pain for 4 days; it literally woke me up in the morning. It wasn't minor. It was enough for me to call the owner and basically tell him I had a bad experience. I didn't plan on writing a review at all actually, and wanted to be direct that I was dissatisfied. So I figured I'd call.

The guy couldn't even talk for one second and was so defensive he hung up on me twice. My point wasn't to pick a fight, it was to say as a customer that I had an issue with the latest pizza order. The guy was/is so rude though all he could do was run away from the conversation and blame me for "trying something. " Pathetic experience and a joke of a business owner. Better pizza and customer service elsewhere.

We have been searching for the best pizza in Sarasota county and I think we finally found it.
The crust was perfect, not too thick not paper thing. Excellent fresh flavors.

Pizza bakers should be able to take pride in the finished product. I can't imagine being proud of the pie from this establishment. The crust was like flattened wonder bread. It was so uniform that I would guess it was commercialy produced. The cheese had a dry consistency but the other toppings were good. Limp crust one star because it was on time

The owner of the place in old man is the only one works. You going to get the best pizza you can have in Sarasota? I recommend it to everybody. There's no service. There's no restaurant. There's no employees. Good food, good food, good food

Incredible pizza and pasta dishes. Also the best selection of vegan/meatless options on the planet. My fiance and I couldnt live without this place.

I have no idea how they had such high reviews. Sauce was good, but cheese was definitely questionable.the crust was like eating pure gluten out of a betty crocker pizza packet from grocery store.

The pizza was amazing, best I had in a while, freshly made and piping hot! Would definitely come again.

This one of the best pizza joints in Sarasota. We live in the Palmer Ranch area so it’s only a couple miles from our house making it very convenient. Last Friday night we ordered a large pepperoni & mushroom pizza and it was great! Their large pizza is 16” but seemed bigger. The toppings, cheese and sauce were right to the edge of the crust. The overall flavor was excellent and robust! I got there just as it came out of the oven so it was still nice and hot by the time I got home. Best of all it was only $19.63! I have paid more for smaller pizzas. We had a couple slices for leftovers the following day and they were delicious! Great pizza and a good value!