The New York Pizza Company, Kissimmee FL

Really good New York style pizza and calzones. They use good ingredients and it shows. The owner cares for his business and their customers. Definitely give them a try. We’ve been going here for years.

Love this place wen they get it right! Gave 3 stars simply because the pizza was undercooked and the baked ziti needed more salt. The pinwheels needed for the meat to be put inside while u bake it not added on top after also wasn’t cooked thoroughly.garlic knots r on point tho

The person who appears to be the owner was very nice and very accommodating. Makes me feel real bad to say this but the food we ordered was not the best. Sauce was watered down and there wasn’t much flavor to it.

I want to preface this review by saying the pizza from here tastes great. I really enjoyed the pizza until one day I bit into a large barbed chunk of metal that was sandwiched and cooked into a slice of pizza I had. Upon removing it I discovered this was a very concerning large piece of what appears to be a spikey and wired piece of aluminum. I called the store up to explain what happened and spoke with the owner, Alex. He provided me his e-mail which I followed-up with contacting him privately.

I sent him photos and asked if he would be willing to work with me to try to figure out what happened. I requested a formal investigation occur so other customers don’t experience serious injuries or possibly death from a similar encounter. Alex claimed that he made the dough himself and it never sees metal (which I believe) and that he doesn’t know where it originated from (which I also believe).

However, I think it’s even more concerning that we can’t even explain how this large object found its way into food served to the public. He offered me a refund and some free pizzas, but it seems like a marginal effort to appease me and doesn’t address or prevent any future problems from occurring. Maybe this metal was mixed in with the toppings? Maybe there was malice involved and it was cooked into the pizza? The point is a serious effort to address it hasn’t been made since I contacted him over a week ago. I filed a report with the Florida Department of Health and have taken my business elsewhere. I’d recommend others do the same unless you don’t care about foreign objects getting cooked in your food with no efforts at trying to figure out where it may have come from.

Best New York pizza in the area. Service is pretty consistently terrible but the pizza is top notch. Dining room is usually messy and/or dirty so take-out is the best way to go.

Yo you guys hit it spot on with the taste of your pizza. I mean i literally could not find a good pizza joint but you guys are now my number 1. Great price and taste. 100 percent delicious!

First time eating there and let me tell you super amazing thin and just taste great best pizza I have had here in Florida

Today I went there order two pizza with all veggie and pepperoni, we order at 6: 10 got our food at 6: 40 Dining in, the veggie were cold not cooked at all very disappointed with level of service we got there, we ask for our money back never coming back seems the ppl who order on line gets better service.

I am not even sure how the food tastes. Their customer service was so bad I didn’t even bother ordering food. I’ll stick to my other pizza shop a mile away.

A little hidden gem! Awesome Italian food at great prices. Their pasta dinners are delicious and they have white sauce, which is really rare for little spots like this. The biggest reason I chose to do this review though is their garlic knots. AHH-MAZING! Seriously. Consistently tasty every time. Other places it’s hit or miss, but not here. Not too much garlic, super soft and baked perfectly. So good.

I had the pizza and cheese bread delivered. The pizza was VERY salty and could not eat it, and I like salt. The cheese bread was burned. I was really hoping to find a great pizza place - save your money.

The pizza is fresh and delicious. I have been driving 30minutes for over a year every time to get this pizza. However, nobody in there is wearing a FACE MASK very disgusted after seeing this went I picked up my pizza

Foods great but the services is horrible for dine in and carry out. Most recent poor experience I had was trying to order some dam pizza to pick up. I called three separate times spread out. Each time a woman answered before I could get a word out she’d tell me to please hold. A couple of minutes would go by then she’d hang up on me. I understand being busy and needing to put someone on hold but to hang up without a word three times seems intentional. Why even have a phone for ordering then?

Good Pizza Bad service
Waited 20 m for 2 slice re heat and when complained about it was told that I was wrong and refused to refund. I had to leave without lunch nor my money as my lunch break was over.

The pizza here is great. The price is as well. Staff us very friendly and helpful. My son left his phone here. They charged it and called me to let me know it was found. That was awesome.

Was craving pizza, so came here on a whim. Got a salad, a couple slices of pizza and a dessert, and everything was amazing. The Greek salad was probably the best I've ever had, I only wish I lived closer! The gentleman doing the checking out was super kind and helpful and the price was not bad at all! I will definitely come back next time I'm in town!

Cured my craving!

Over 2 hours and 2 phone calls to get part of our our order. Our “hot” wings were about as mild and dry as they could be. We ordered 4 ranch and got 2, ordered 1 garlic cheese bread and got 0. Our Diet Coke was actually hot. Upside, pizza was not bad. Very disappointed.

This place continues to go downhill. Called in my order but had to wait more than 20 minutes for my very cold food. Pizza was chewy and sauce was incredibly bitter. Won’t go back.

Our new favorite pizza place! Pizza is nice and big. Love the thin crust, and the fact that there is always just enough cheese and sauce. Best of all, you can’t beat the price of the specials. Definitely worth trying folks

Update 01/05/2020:
Pizza is still good, but it took over half an hour for a personal cheese pizza because my ticket got lost. I also watched as 2 parties that came after me got their pizza first. I have second thoughts about coming here again.