Fatty's Pizza, Macon GA

Lunch special was great, 2 slices and a drink less than $6.00. Staff was friendly. Highly recommend for a quick lunch.

The service was good and friendly. The pizza was delicious. It was thin but doughy and the cheese pull was beautiful. To top it off they have a $5 deal where you get two slices of this delicious pizza and a 16 oz drink.

OMG. GREAT NY style pizza!

Like all good pizza places, they have 2 slices & drink for $5.26

Love this place! Professional staff, clean restrooms, and the pizza was perfectly cooked with LOTS of toppings!

Well I’m from fl and the pizza was banging. The guy who is the manager was a great dude. Made the experience better he was down to earth. We eat pizza with our 6 kids around 1 time a week maybe. And they loved the pizza as well as my picky gf.

Had the chubby (small) calzone. Very good. Staff was attentive as had other customers ahead of me but still acknowledged me. Always a plus.

I would give the downtown location 5 stars. But I have tried the Tom Hill location several times and it’s terrible. Please get this location up to par or it will ruin the reputation of what I once thought to be the best pizza in Macon. I live closer to Tom Hill but I will bypass this location going forward and just head downtown.

Very disappointed with the quality of the personal sized pizza! It was mostly doughy crust and looked NOTHING like the pictures on their website. Maybe a quirk of this new location. I'll try the downtown location as well!

Great pizza, $$ for sure, super long wait. Lady forgot to make our breadsticks, quoted us 7 min. 22 min later we get a free pizza and wings? But no breadsticks! And by that time the pizzas we actually ordered were cold when we got home

Really good pizza and cheese bread I didn't care for the marinara sauce it was to tangy but the employees were friendly and the food was good. Definitely recommend this place

This place has gone down hill, the employees are horrible, the last two times we have been the pizza has been horrible, this time it was literally stuck to the bottom of the box and tasted like actual cardboard

Went here on Jan 8,2022. Bad service and food poisoning. First thing I noticed when we (me and my girlfriend walked in) was the service was shoddy. The lady up front acted like she really didn't want to be there at all. We ordered our food and sat down. All the tables were dirty, we picked the cleanest looking table. We sat down and waited... And waited. It took forever to get our food. And there was only us and one other "party" there. It should NOT have taken so long. It was like they forgot about us. When we finally got our food (one pizza, garlic kinks, and a calzone) our food was cold. My girlfriend started feeling sick about halfway through the meal, and when we walked out to the truck, she was throwing up. When I got home that night, my stomach was churning, and I stayed up half the night sick. Will NOT be going back.

Good pizza and wings, fountain machine has watered-down sodas, tea was delicious. Manager responded to our concerns, nice visit

It's been about two years since I've visited the downtown location but I have visited the Tom Hill location recently. I remember the pizza tasting so much better & having more ingredients than what I received when visiting recently. Hopefully, they will work the kinks out as my order took approximately a half hour longer than they said it would. I really want to like this establishment b/c past experiences, years back were good. Is it me or does the owner only reply to the positive reviews? They should definitely address some of the negative reviews that have been posted by some here. The customer ISN'T always right but the customer does have a right to be satisfied with a product that they are spending their money on. You definitely don't want people to think that the passion for making a good product has been replaced by the passion of just making good money. Good Luck Fatty's Pizza, I'm rooting for you but don't brush off some of the concerns listed by your patrons.

Supposed to pick up at 5: 55pm. Waited another 25 minutes in store. Guy in the back was busy arguing with and cursing at someone over the phone. No apologies given. There's that.

I’ve been visiting Fatty’s on Tom Hill since the summer months. I enjoyed their pizza. But recently I have been very dissatisfied with the product and the employees. For the second time, my personal pizzas dough was not cooked! Box was heavy when I picked it up and now I know why…it was full of uncooked dough! SMH. The wings were not done and had barely no sauce. The employees were just hanging out, talking and not paying attention to my food. I threw it all away. I’m done!

Was staying overnight near here. I always try to order from local places to support non chain restaurants. Unfortunately Fatty's would not deliver even though the sure says delivery. So if they hate making money the only choice for me was call another place.