Amish Market, New York NY

Great selection of Olive Oils in particular as well a vast variety of top notch food items any traveler might want, to satisfy an impromptu get together.

I walked in and walked right out. Where was the amish food or even amish people. The name is deceiving. I live in a state where the amish are everywhere. I only eat amish food. I know the difference.

Amish food has no preservatives so it spoils faster. The amish market I go to has a ton of selections. This place was limited. If the cheese doesn't come from Beemster.it's not amish. If the muffins don't have 6 ingredients.its not amish. Amish means no preservatives. I saw tons of preservatives there.

I like the selection of goods in Amish market, you can find almost everything you need, however almost everything is significantly overpriced, 1.5-2 times higher (not exaggerating) then if you use grocery delivery services or other large grocery chains.

My wife bought a pumpkin pie they made there on Thanksgiving and we didn’t end up eating it. The next day when we went to eat it, it was covered in little mold spores. Absolutely disgusting they obviously don’t handle their food properly for it to go bad in one day despite being in the fridge but the worst part is that when my wife went to go return it they were unapologetic. Even though it said Amish market and was still packaged they wanted a receipt to refund her and gave her issues trying to figure out if she did something to cause mold on a still packaged pie. Then finally they gave her store credit and when she went to the counter the woman tried to charge her full price even though twice she said she had $20 store credit for the pie. Again no apology. If you are running a store that you don’t care if you sell moldy baked goods and are not apologetic about it I would be VERY concerned about the quality and integrity of all of their products.

Amish Market need to get there act together. There are a few issues i find the fruits are not fresh avocado oranges apple plums spoiled very quickly, very expensive, the avocado if cut a few piece if you leave the rest it turn black, the bread not tasty if leave over for a few day stared to get hard, the market and it products needed to revamp. The service and staff are wonderful.

They have lots of hard to find stuff at your typical grocery store. Sometimes a little busy in the morning but never too bad.

No time-consuming or confusing order forms here! The man who helped me knew what merchandise was in stock and made sure it got to her doorman. I really, really appreciated the Amish Market's personal touch when I had to send food to my mom after her surgery.

Amish market has a great selection of prepared foods as well as a salad bar. They also have a pastry counter and everything is delicious! Good raw meat and chicken area. Have gotten helpful tips for preparing.