Aunt Cookies Sub Shop, Geneseo NY

I always come here when I work in geneseo and while I'm not big on sandwiches/subs this has become a place I enjoy coming to, the owner and staff are very friendly as well I went in for lunch yesterday and my card wasn't working so I paid cash I only had a $10 on me so I told her to put the chips back she told me to grab some anyway

Subs were awesome, quite busy so plan a wait or call ahead. Great lunch after flying at the National Warplane Museum.

1st time here, and their subs are absolutely yummy and delicious! Next time, i want to try their chocolate chip cookies and other subs. Perfect for lunch and dinners. I highly recommend coming here for a yummy subs.

Best Italian sub in the business, clean, friendly! Laurie was amazing, absolutely nailed it all! Would come down from Florida again for that good of a sub… and the cookies are great as well.

25 years in the Geneseo area and I had never been here. I had my first sub here about a year ago, and it's my Go To now for subs. Absolutely delicious.

Could not speak more highly of this place. The Italian sub I got here was the best I’ve ever had. Service was incredibly friendly. Will be returning!

The subs are absolutely terrific. Toasted Italian sub roll with lots of meat and the proper amount of lettuce, mayo, oil and tomatoes.
Turkey, ham, Italian and roast beef subs are all great.
Fast friendly service. College town sub shop atmosphere.
And yes, the cookies are very good too.

The sub sandwiches here are really freaking good and they have an awesome selection to pic from too. Plus their prices are pretty cheap as well.

I decided to come here for the first time the other day, despite going to Geneseo since 2020. I have no idea why I haven’t been here sooner. The subs are so delicious, the pickles are so fresh and crispy and a whole sub is very reasonably priced. It is convenient that you can place an order online so I can just grab it and go. Cannot wait to be back in the fall and have another delicious sub from aunt cookies!

I went to aunt cookies in 1980 when I was at geneseo and had to visit again now that my daughter is there. Still amazing subs. Not the same feel as when I was there but still great.