Bakery Plus, Middletown NY

Had ordered a cannoli birthday cake. It was on time and soooo delicious. Everyone enjoyed it. The people that work there are so nice. Highly recommend

I wholeheartedly and without hesitation give Bakery plus a 5 star review. You will not find cakes or deserts better than the ones that are prepared here. The owners are great people and friendly also. I have been a customer for decades and have never been disappointed. Neither will you, Go check them out.

Bakery Plus! Simply the best! You can’t get this quality anywhere else! Love to get lost in a decadent desert of Bakery Plus! Only the best for me….

There Carrot cake is so moist and delicious, my daughter loves there cakes. Everything and reasonably priced and the staff is very friendly.

Purchased two GF cupcakes here today, 9.7.2023. Owner is super nice and the two GF cupcakes were outstanding!

Best bakery in Orange County! Everything is delicious! The owners are wonderful and we believe in keeping small businesses alive! 5 star bakery

My friend's son was having a graduation party and she made him a cake but her dogs ruined it! The day of the party! I went to Bakery Plus, and they had a sheet cake and decorated it beautifully! It was delicious too! My new go to!

Called. Them this morning to order a birthday cake for my wife asked her a couple questions she says to me I don’t have time for I’m so busy do graduation cakes hog to my website then hangs up on me without saying anything she is so rude & unprofessional I don’t know how she stays in business acting like that to customers I’ll take my money to another bakery she’s not the only bakery around

We have loved this bakery for decades. They had the best caramel walnut apple pie in the world. While they no longer make the pie, everything else is amazing, like chocolate mousse slices, tiramisu cakes, raspberry cheesecakes and other specialty items. Love this business.

I purchased an ice cream cake for my daughter birthday. Everyone loves it. We will be ordering from here for now on.

Cakes are good but owner seems overworked and overwhelmed. Unfortunately her customers get the brunt of it.

Picked up some delicious treats here and the woman serving us answered all our questions and was very nice

The cakes, cupcakes, cookies I mean you name it they make it and make it incredibly delicious and decadent! Their chocolate mouse is like eating a chocolate cloud! I ordered most recently a red velvet cake for my sisters birthday and it was done fresh and decorated nicely. They are so easy to work with! They are also very thoughtful because I ordered a cake for someone and they realized some already bought a cake for that same person and she let me know right away that she thinks we might have double cakes. And we did lol but that just shows how much everyone loves them!

Wow just had an ice cream cake it was to die for. Such great flavor Have been a customer for many years They are the best
Thank you for my great desert as always

I called to get a price and to ask a question and she told me that I have to go on the website to ask my question that she has people in front of her.then if thats the case why even answer the phone. How rude. I don't think a website could answer my question all needed was a spider man cake that feeds 100 people. I'll guess I'll take my money somewhere else. I will be letting all my friends no how rude this place is. If she was a professional then she should have took my number and called me back. I will be ordering my cakes from Walmart from now on. I thought I could support a local business but she to good to answer a question

Not only are the cakes AMAZING but the family who runs it are all so lovely! Always friendly and happy to make your cake your way! Highly recommend! The cannoli cake with whip cream is to DIE for! I would have added a photo but we ate it too fast!:)