Brooklyn's Finest Pizza, Staten Island NY

We thought we ordered a pizza but we ended up with a meat and cheese sandwich sort of thing. The cheese was bad so I took it off but everything else on the dish I really enjoyed, the meat was good and it had a great flavour and taste.

I ordered the grandma pizza and it was delicious! The staff was awesome and delivery was so fast

My order was perfect.fresh, and ready on time. Even tho I used a coupon - from grubhub. I feel like they made my order exactly as if I paid full price. Some places make adjustments when you use coupons and make portions smaller. Not at BROOKLYNS FINEST. Highly recommend.

Cannot read or fulfill any requests or additions even if charged for it. Super annoyed to have payed extra on DoorDash for the bare minimum expectation to be ruined to the worst. Your food is good but not that good to jsut eat without any sauces extra seasoning or items that were request with the food. Next time fulfill all DoorDash requests as ordered. It’s not like it’s free or as if you are being courteous when You charge for every little item…. If you arnt dining in to correct every mistake in person don’t order. Cause they won’t help reimburse or do anything about it but say I’m sorry.

I tried their buffalo shrimp pizza and it’s one of the best I’ve had, hands down. Not greasy, good sauce, perfectly cooked.

I went here twice recently. I had the plain slices which were fine and I had a hero with Steak, Mozz, Onions and Peter Luger sauce I thought it was pretty decent. The prices are extremely reasonable, the service was courteous and helpful. I liked it and will return.

First time here and decided to try the Cauliflower Crust Pizza - Absolutely delicious! I’ve had other local pizza’s and this one was the best, will definitely come again! (Prices are very reasonable)

We went there for our son and daughter in law's gender reveal really had a nice time it's small but cute

Not sure why they're getting bad reviews? They probably out due their competition with the amount of food for the price. This place is the best and the neighborhood heroes are always on point especially the "east New York" and the "gerritsen beach" heroes.

There are 1000 pizzerias on this island, GO ELSEWHERE! Don’t spend your money here, food is horrible and so is the delivery service

The Penny Vodka pie was fabulous.never disappointed. The delivery was fast and food was hot. Thank you

I never write reviews but I felt it was necessary after our second consecutive mishap.

We order often, especially for the Chicken Rice Soup which is really quite good. However, two separate times in a row now they have sent a partial order and this time without a receipt. I called once I received the order missing items and without a receipt and the counter girl kindly apologized and said the missing contents were ready and would be sent immediately. It’s only been an hour and twenty minutes but I’m sure my broccoli roll will get here soon!

Update: It didn’t get here, I called and told them they can keep the roll and the money. Such a shame, we’ve really enjoyed their food in the past but they won’t get a third chance from us. Maybe you will have better luck.

Brooklyn's Finest Pizzeria delicious selection, lots of options, great entrees, heroes and everything in between. Always a great selection of fresh slices on display - great value! And most of all Fast Free Delivery!

I love having Brooklyn’s Finest delivered. The food tastes great and consistent quality. Hubby must have his veal parm and I opted for greek salad with grilled chicken. Cheese pizza is perfect and the baked ziti is worth a try.