Cafora's Pizza Italian Restaurant, Newfane NY

Great food. Friendly service. Small town family feel. We go often and have never been let down. I love the lasagna and French onion soup but their pizza and wings are great too. Nice selection of entrees.

Been going there since moving to Newfane in 1991. Food always good but service has gone way downhill. Waitress brought me a refill on a drink but never asked my wife if she wanted one. Same waitress, second time this has happened. Then get the bill and price is higher than the menu. $60 for a pizza and wings that used to be $40 Asked and was told I should watch the news that everything has gone up. Put it on the menu then and dont price gouge your regulars. $25 for wings? RIPOFF. Bandanas in Youngstown is $17 same size.

Great pizza! This place didn't disappoint. Cozy restaurant in a cute small town. I was happy to see it busy. Excellent service too!

I grew up in an Italian household so I'm very picky about marinara sauce. I used to live in the Buffalo area but have since moved to Oklahoma. I was hankering for some good Western New York Italian. This absolutely hit the spot. You've got to try the antipasto. It's amazing. The lasagna was also excellent.

This cozy restaurant is owned by my husband's friend.i have had other italian "authentic" food and have been disappointed.cafora's is truly authentic.the food here is so delicious and worth the price.portions are so large we even have food plus a pizza for dinner tomorrow night.thank you bobby and staff for a wonderfully enjoyable dining experience.we will be back as often as we can.y'all are the bomb.

Cozy, locally owned Italian restaurant. Casual attire, delivery available. Offers a wide range of Italian foods - something for everyone You are served a warm, tasty loaf of bread while you wait for your order. Service is outstanding as is the food. I highly recommend you stop in for a dinner or pizza.

Staff was very polite and food was relatively good. The bread takes this place into the four star rating along with the good staff. I had the eggplant parm and meatballs. Both above expectations and good.

“Pornogastric red gorgonzola cheese without onion” so highly recommended? We took away and enjoy it under the sunset

Average food. Average service. Alfredo was soupy and tasted like half & half. Chicken Parm was good.

We had a friendly waitress but she took a LONG time to take our order and then it also took a while to actually get our food. We were the only customers in there at the time (shortly after they opened), so we couldn't understand what good so long. Good food though when it finally came.

Delicious sandwiches! The bread is out of this world! Excellent service! I haven't been here in years. I will definitely be back!

Been eating there for 20 years nothing but love for cafora's we order at least two times a week never ever did we get a bad meal I love cafora's

Waited an hour and a half for our soggy cold food they forgot our salads haven't been to impressed lately. Only thing that was good was the salad not sure there will be a next time it's a shame to same that because they used to be really good

Cafora's is hands down the best in the area. They use to have a restaurant in Medina and was heart broken when they closed. So now I drive 30 min to their newfane location. Their pizza is the BEST! Highly recommend stopping in for some good food, and a relaxing setting.

Had an excellent experience, our waitress Kelly was amazing. Will return. Thank you kelly for being you keep up the good work!

This our go-to place for pizza. Their white Hawaiian pizza is awesome. Don't knock it till you try it. The dine-in selection is also pretty awesome. The do an excellent chicken parm, and the steak ponzone is a favorite of mine. I recently tried their chicken Caesar salad and it was great. I tend to order the same thing when I'm a regular customer at a place. Why take a chance on ordering an unknown you might not enjoy? When I *have* tried something new here it's always been good, which creates a dilemma. When you like a bunch of things how do you choose? Not a bad dilemma I guess.