Cait's Key Lime, Brooklyn NY

First time trying Cait's Key Lime Pie that was given to me by a close friend.
I couldn't believe how delicious this pie tastes! It really hit the spot!
It's lemony sweet, mouthwatering, addictive and packs a punch that's full of flavors too!
I actually saved the lid, this way I can order some in the near future especially during the upcoming holidays.

Seriously, the best pie I've ever had. Perfectly balanced, each bite just had me going back for more! It was an easy ordering process and Cait is awesome!

Best key lime pie! Can’t wait to buy it one day at Yankee Stadium. If you haven’t tried it yet…you must!

Best pie ever! Me and my coworkers get the mini pies atleast once a week (sometimes more) THEYRE ADDICTIVE! I CAITS KEY LIME PIES!

I LOVE (love love) CAIT'S KEY LIME PIE - i didnt even like key lime pie, and then I had Cait's and now it's my FAVE. The littles are great for events and parties and on the go - and the big guy has a luxurious integrity - so much tartness, so much creaminess, and the fresh lime shavings - I DIE. Also, Cait is the coolest and easiest and loveliest to work with whether for your dinner party, your event or just your personal key lime addiction. GET ON THE INTERWEBS and get yourself some pie!

SHE'S SWEET! SHE'S TART! SHE'S THE PERFECT DINNER COMPANION! THE PEOPLE"S PIE! CAITSKEYLIMEFOREVER

TO DIE FOR. I love key lime pie and this is IT! Even better than the marshmallow piped slice of heaven that Llama Inn took off their menu (rip). Perfectly tart with a fluffy filling that doesn’t feel funky and gelatinous. A bold amount of lime zest to spice things up. I’ve gone to Sweet Chick on two separate occasions when it’s already been sold out. They prob call me the key lime pie girl behind my back but I will continue to go and beg for this pie because that’s how good it is.

Seriously one of the best key lime pies I’ve ever eaten—I think about it often! I also love how they come in different sizes. Who doesn’t need a personal key lime pie?

Delicious graham crust and fresh lime zest accent the most perfect ratio of silky custard to fluffy whip you’ve ever seen/tasted. If you took time to snap a pic, you’re better than me… mine doesn’t stick around long enough to pose for photos. Best pie, forks down. 5 stars isn’t enough.

YALLLLLL this is the best key lime pie I’ve ever had. And I’ve had a lot of key lime pie. It’s so well balanced, light, refreshing, and delicious— this is the only dessert I’ll be having from now on.

Cait’s key lime pie is the best in the city! Hands down.i’m usually not a key lime pie guy, but I am a cait’s key lime pie guy for SURE!

Hands down best pies i’ve ever had and cait is the sweetest person! 100/10 would recommend

The best key lime pie I have ever had. Maybe actually the best pie I have ever had, seriously. I dream about this pie! We got them in mini size for an event and they were a hit! The crust is the perfect texture, and the filling is the perfect balance of sweet and tart. You can tell the ingredients are super fresh and carefully sourced, nothing tastes artificial or overly sweet. Truly a Queen amongst desserts.

NOTE: this is an online biz, so order from the site and arrange delivery:)

Truly the best key lime pie i have ever had. 10/10 would recommend! If you pull up to any function with this dessert you are doing gods work:)

I have an upcoming exam in just an hour, but I wanted to take a moment to share my thoughts about these amazing pies. Throughout my life I've had many key lime pies, yet Cait’s key limes stands out as an absolute favorite.

Best. Pie. Ever.
Sweetest packaging & best customer service. So delicious & not overly sweet, perfect amount of creamy and limey. Love it

The pie was absolutely delicious! Such an easy and great experience with ordering and picking up! Highly recommend giving it a try!

One of the best key lime pies Ive ever had! Note: this is not a storefront. You must order via her website