Caledonia Bar, New York NY

Got one drink with a friend, only to get aggressively confronted by the bartender midway about how he barely gets paid and it's my job to pay him by tipping nicely. Ruined the night out and definitely would not recommend

My first time visiting this bar. No food this night, but the bar was packed and one bartender (possibly Billy) was handling it all with ease. I will definitely go out of my way and make a return visit. 10/10 selection of scotch, bourbons & whisky.

They dropped the salt into the fries like as if you were on a salt farm - also, if you order fries, is it to much to expect other sauces than ketchup?

The bartender charged me for an extra cocktail. It was too dark to see when I was handed the bill. Not cool.

I like going here alone. Good drinks and quiet. Average or below average food. I think it's quiet for the sane and reasons it's quiet. It's catered to an older crowd

This place is a great upscale neighborhood bar! Caledonia Bar on the UWS serves am endless selection of whiskey, beer, and cocktails - definitely get the Bee's Knees Cocktail! Staff is super friendly and the service is quick! The place is nicely decorated, ambience is great, and their playlist has lots of 80s music! I wish I came here earlier!

Drinks, when made correctly were good. With that said, two out of the three I ordered wereade incorrectly. The food was good, albeit cold - it took nearly forty minutes to come (just a burger).

Seems like the issues were mostly due to them being understaffed for a friday night. I'll try it again, but with all the rest of the bars in the area it'll probably be a while until I do.

Most probably the worst place north of Times Square. Revolting food. Terrible attitude from the bartender. Funny there were three of us who bought food/drinks separately. Each said the bartender had a horrible attitude. My friend who was a bartender for years during her college days and always tips very well; this is the first time in her life she's left no tip. Absolute trash worker. Zero stars for service. Zero stars for food (burger actually wasn't bad, but Mac and cheese was revolting). Four stars for design and ambiance. The bar next door is substantially better.