Carroll Place, New York NY

I had the grilled branzino which was outstanding - the skin was delightfully crispy! My husband had the lasagna and it was also amazing and deceptively light! The menu online for drinks has changed and I don't see the amazing mezcal creation that I had (maybe it's been added since the menu was posted?).

I haven't been this excited about a restaurant in a long time!

They have a group menu that was pretty worth it for value ($40/person) but the food itself was not good.

The only things that stood out were the salads.

Salmon was Smokey but not salted, the pasta felt overcooked, pizza was very whatever (bread was decent) etc. I’d say this is more of a bar than a food place.

Came here for the brunch / happy hour. Was a fantastic price considering the price of the rest of the menu. Mondy our server was top tier, very friendly and helpful!

Our drinks were tasty and the food was also good, thoroughly enjoyable

Great place for happy hour apps and drinks for a group. There was also a fun band playing in the back after happy hour. I’ll be back.

Ordered strange pizza with panchetta. They brought it with cabbage. The taste was weird. On the first floor, I ordered 3 cocktails, 2 negroni, and 1 tequila sunrise.the bartender charged 77 dollars.i think overpriced a lot.was shocked. The atmosphere is fun. Nice authentic place

Great bottomless deal, with tasty food. I highly recommend the rosemary wings. Fast service as well.

He needed to close up and we weren’t ready so instead of kicking us out they were really kind and gave us dessert. I appreciate it they made another place outside for us and the manager Steve was so thoughtful. They really try to make it work and the food was delicious

Aiden was so amazing. He was attentive to our needs above and beyond after i was having a bad day. In the words of Aiden "Nice people do Nice things for nice people" He was very appreciative us being nice. Sergio was an absolute pleasure and was our starting bartender/server and delivered perfectly before his break.

Be prepared to pay $40 for two Tito’s!
But other than that really fun environment and dancing space

I ordered food here late night because it said I could online and went to pick it up and they were closed. Guy said he'd give me refund but I never received a refund. Annoyed.

Old reliable, can’t go wrong if you have a group dinner or date in the area. There’s usually availability to reserve a spot and they have a ton of seating.

Used to love this place and have been here many times pre covid. I came in at around 10: 30 last night for a drink and was shocked to have had such a negative experience with the female bartender working. She was extremely nasty to me from the beginning of our interaction. She demanded I give back my drink that she had just given me and basically threw the money I had just paid for it (and tip) back at me, simply because I initially asked for something different than what she gave me and politely let her know. It didn’t have to be a big deal but she made it one with her confrontational attitude. Not sure if she was having a bad day but it shouldn’t matter. You don’t speak to others that way, especially customers. I barely go out anymore and people like that remind me why. Safe to say I won’t be back for a while.

Food was good-bartender Adrian was even better. They had a great band tonight but insisted on keeping the recorded music on. It was just a muddy audio mess at the bar. Turn the music off and let the band play!

A former historical gay bar, speakeasy, and music club has now transformed into a beautifully antique themed restaurant right by West Village.

Aiden, our bartender, was the best I’ve ever had. We stumbled upon this place on a way to a show and were so, so pleasantly surprised. Really excellent drinks and the best service!

My wife and I swung by Carroll Place for some drinks and munchies, and boy, did we have a good time! We're huge Burrata fans, so we couldn't resist ordering that as our appetizer. Alongside it, we grabbed a cold beer and a nice glass of wine. Let me tell you, that appetizer was on point! They served it up with these bread strips made from pizza dough that were perfectly cooked. We happily dunked those bad boys in the delicious glaze on the Burrata.

The service was on the ball too. Our drinks and appetizer arrived faster than you can say "cheers! " We got so into the vibe of the place that we ended up hanging out longer than planned, just shootin' the breeze and enjoying more drinks. Carroll Place gave us a night to remember, and we're already plotting our next visit. Trust me, you won't be disappointed if you give it a go!