Chosen One Collectible Toys, West Babylon NY

Walked in the store for the first time today with my very young children. It was so much fun browsing the toys with my son. He was able to pick up a small $5 dollar item for himself, while I got myself a Hot Toy that I've been wanting for a while. Karl was so super duper nice and helpful. I wish I had found this store sooner. So many toys ranging from inexpensive items, to Neca, Funkpop, and of course Hot Toys. I've never been in a store with so many Hot Toys figures. I'm very happy this store is a 40 minute drive from me. I can't wait to go back with my son and have some more fun!

I've been going to Chosen One Collectables for over 3 years!
I've bought 95 percent of my figures from them!
They are extremely great people,
Very friendly and helpful!
They also do pre orders and they also let you pay your item off with payment that makes it a little easier to collect!
I only have great things to say about the three people that run the place!
Plus I'm still a loyal customer

Great selection of Pops and Hot Toys, I like going in person to pick out my items, knowing exactly what I'll get! Much better than rolling the dice online with some of those secondhand sites. Staff is always incredibly nice and helpful everytime I shop there.

Has nice selection of toys more hot toys then most places some newer stuff isn’t that off price or not gonna mind but something’s that have been sitting on shelves for sometime have yet to get any sort of markdown or discount in order to sell even when the item is damaged or has box damage even with the small discount they offer still makes the price above market value on Mercari or eBay

The best comic store in town. Very satisfied purchase. Lady who is in charge pretty helpful recommended+

Great place if your into buying or collecting action figures from marvel legends to mezco to hot toys they have it all will definitely come back

Great store! Fantastic selection of collectable toys and action figures! Staff was super friendly and helpful and the prices were very reasonable, will definitely be back!

10/10. Great brick & mortar store in West Babylon. Huge selection of toys & collectibles. Great selection of hot toys & statues. Highly recommend.

This place has a great selection and have bought from them before. HOWEVER the last time I went with my boyfriend, we got yelled at by the woman working there. We were holding a Star Wars action figure which was $20 and the woman said we needed her to get it for us and there was a sign “right in front of our faces”. We tried saying oh sorry we didn’t see it only to be responded with an attitude. There was only a small new sign which was never there prior. She was very rude and disrespectful. It’s a shame because we were going to buy it but I was so turned off by her attitude we put it down and left. Unfortunately we will never go back. I highly recommend a different collectible store, such as the one in Babylon village, which has the same items and the man working there is very nice and welcoming to his customers!

Chosen one is a great place! Nice selection of products. Dani was super kind, welcoming and super helpful! Highly recommend!

Always a great selection, Karl and the rest of the staff are always pleasant and knowledgeable!

It's a great place for collectable figures, plushies, blind boxes. They have Back to the future, The Walking Dead, Masters of the Universe, Gremlins, Transformers, Star Wars, FNAF, Buffy, Ghostbusters, Game of Thrones. It's worth checking out.