Cindy's Pies, Naples NY

Their grape pies and cookies are the best and their prices are really reasonable.

This was our first time wanting to try here since Monica’s pies were always our favorite but they obviously closed. Anyways me and my mom drove three hours and waited in line in the rain for 45 minutes to be told they only have 3 pies left in the over as she then auctioned them by saying “I’m not sure if anyone wants one but it’s going to be 15 minutes” so I raised my hand immediately. In fact I was the only one who raised my hand until two people in the front saw me. Mind you I was the third person in line. But a women in front of us with her husband last mine after saying they were together and wanted one pie. So I was told I would get one of the three. Then the women decided she wanted the last pie because she was infront of me and she said because she can have two. I don’t think that was fair whatsoever. She didn’t say the first three in line if you want them. Nope my mom was a witness that they were auctioned and I raised my hand first but was completely dismissed. Me and my mom usually spent a lot of money on these pies and for this being our first time. The women running the window was absolutely wrong for how she handled that situation. You should have honored the pie I raised my hand for considering NO ONE else raised their hands until they looked at me when the women in the window pointed at me. Then she just allowed everyone else to claim them and said sorry they want two so you won’t get one after I waited and was originally pointed at and told I was going to get the pie. But because she as a worked made the mistake with how she worded it etc she should have honored me getting one pie. Not to mention it’s not fair for others to get more than one. You should have said one per hand raised period. That’s how she announced it and then I was the only one told yes and then told nope sorry because the women infront of me was a horrible human and rude. I don’t think this is how management should handle things. All those poor people who waited for almost an hour if not longer to be told nope. Why didn’t you count your inventory and keep track so people with kids aren’t standing in the rain to be told no sorry we messed up. Anyways, we will not recommend or be returning. We definitely wish Monica’s stayed open. She always had inventory and made sure to have backups. Sad we were hoping to find something close to hers but this won’t be a place we even try again. Good luck next year. Hopefully you have someone running the window that knows how to handle a situation like that. Because we were treated unfair and disrespectful. That wasn’t right of you guys.

Vacationing from out of state and enjoying the local wines?
Then you need to try the grape pie or at least the cookies, simply amazing and delicious!

Stopped in curious to try the Grape Pie. You can get either crumb or regular top we got the crumb It was absolutely spectacular and still warm. We will be stopping to grab a few before we start our drive home to Pa. We also grabbed two cherry tarts to eat in the car on the way to our air b&b which were also delish! If you’re in the area make Cindy’s a must try!

I didn’t think I was going to like the grape pie, since I had tried one from another place in the past and wasn’t impressed. Theirs was honestly so good. The right balance of sweet and tart with a delicious, flaky crust. The grape filled cookies are so good too.

Cindy's are really the best grape pies in the town. We get them annually! Also, love the raspberry and cherry tarts.