Collectors Coins & Jewelry of Baldwin

My name is Elmer I came today on the 29th of November and I came to sell my coins and everything went great these guys are awesome great vibes

This establishment was incredibly helpful! The guy Jeffrey that runs the place is an absolute gentleman. I asked him to test and weigh my jewelry, he was more than happy to do so and refused to accept any payment. He was a pleasure to deal with! He schooled me on some things I was unaware of, and was extremely patient with me. He took his time and couldn’t have been nicer. I was taken back because he wasn’t making much off of me but was still willing to take his time, and share his knowledge. These qualities are so rare in business owners today. A few days later he allowed me to sell my jewelry in his store to a stranger. Again, he offered his assistance and resources for a minuscule cost. He made me feel confident and comfortable. I was really surprised at how great these guys were. I very rarely write a review but these guys deserve that, at the least!
I highly, highly, highly recommend this jewelry store for any of your jewelry store needs. Although I wasn’t in the market, I window shopped while I was there. They have a huge selection of beautiful watches and all other jewelry. They are specialists in rare coins and have a huge selection of those as well. If you’re ever in Baldwin Ny please stop by, say hello to Jeffrey and show your support! The prices are incredible.
This is now my jewelry store for life. I will certainly be back in the future, and look forward to doing business with Jeffrey. Thank you for everything Sir!

Just had a wonderful experience selling and doing business with Jeffrey. Was very quick and informational and received money upfront. Would 100% buy and resell here again!

Just had my first experience with Jeff and it couldn’t have gone smoother. Don’t hesitate to come in here! He bought some stuff from me and was very fair and easy to work with. Thanks Jeff.

Went in today to sell some silver coins Jeffery was very nice and helpful also very fair on price definitely a great experience

I really don’t like to leave bad reviews but I have tried to get this resolved and this company just does not care. I was sold a watch with the wrong dial. I have attached pics of what I received and what the watch is supposed to be.
I bought a Breitling Navitimer 806 AOPA which serial number dates back to a 1959 model. The watch I received has a dial that was introduced 4 years later.
Jessica handed the phone to a person who claims their name was Chad. He declined my full refund as he thinks these dials were interchangeable. I disagreed and send him proof of different official sources such as 3 Breitling Historians, Boutique approved links to official websites as well as the Boutique confirming my claim. I called 7 times asking to please talk to the owner to plead my case but never received a call back. Since they will not tell me which store should take ownership of this issue and I bought the watch out of state. I am leaving this review on all related stores to the Collectors Coins Jewelry Watches. Again, I have emails, texts, invoice, phone history records and more to prove my claim. If the owner never received my many messages and emails please get with Jessica, Chad and Mike. Your website talks about earning a reputation as experts appraisers but yet you sold me a Franken and will not admit to your mistake. Originality is everything toma collector and it is sad you have people working for you who will not stand behind your own company motto treating people integrity and respect which are neither things I experienced.

I love this place! They have a great collection of items and very fair in prices. Jeffrey has a great knowledge of all things and super helpful when it comes to buying and selling. The little plus side to going in is he's also really cute will always get my business!

Jeff was very polite, and informative about the jewelry and break down of what I getting and he listened to your concern and make sure you understand.
This is definitely my go too place now. I walk out feeling happy with offer I received.