Collegetown Bagels, Ithaca NY

Great selection of scrumptious bagels that are in pair or even better than the ohh so famous NYC ones. Yummy sandwiches, smoothies coffee end things. Ample seating place both inside and out. The friendly staff makes it one of my favorites places to get my morning coffee.

So many choices. All very tasty. Study the extensive menu ahead of time so you don’t tie up the line.

Good breakfast bagel. Brooklyn, bacon egg and cheese. We ordered inside, and ate out side.there was a line but moved quickly. There are also tables to sit and eat inside.

Good bagels. Had a Bronx Bagel with a za'atar bagel, chicken sausage, pepper jack and avacado. I like the mediterranean twist with the Za'atar reminds me of the manakeesh I get back in Buffalo. Definitely give a try

Loved this place for its vibe: came here several times to write/read/think, with a nice chatter behind me, enjoying coffee and a bagel. Can't beat it.

Waited 35 mins for a smoothie, they hadn't started when we went back to ask. Pricey and always busy, why do they call everything bagels 'long island bagels'? !

Great variety of food. Their bagels and coffee are delicious. They’re in the heart of downtown Ithaca so it’s a big go-to spot for breakfast. But the wait for the food is just too long.

We came here 2 times and both times our orders were missing or completely different from what we ordered. Food is amazing but too many orders were messed up.

Lots of selections, vegetarian and vegan. Everything from bagel with cream cheese to design your own grain bowls.

Quality is not as what it used to be. Tastes like Dunkin bagels, no more unique artisan experience

Some items on the menu are not worth the price. I ordered a strawberry smoothie for 6$ and it just tasted like water.

This place has outstanding bagels, coffee and service. It’s exactly what a local bagel shop should be!

I have never written a review for any restaurant so I'm not just someone that always complains.but this was the worst place I've ever been to. I don't mind paying $5 for a coffee, but this cup was more than half foam and no liquid. Desserts were terrible and dry, would not reccomend this place to anyone. Worst $20 I've ever spent.

In terms of Coffee, it is the best in town. The coffee tastes great and they have Delicious Desserts. Prices are reasonable. Customer service are great. I recommend this place for Ithaca visitors. They should try it at least once.

Coffee and bagels are delicious. Ordering process is awkwardly laid out, confusing, and seems unnecessary. "Are you in line? " was all I heard while eating there.

Nice bagel shop with great vibe and food. We ordered to go, the bagels are amazing - juicy and rich.

Big menu for a fairly small space, great beer and kombucha bar, nice service, and terrific decor and seating. Can't wait for the fresh glue smell to disappear.

Local favourite! Excellent breakfast food. Great selection of hot/iced coffees and lattes. Baked goods are excellent. Vegetarian and vegan options available

I am not sure how this place gets good ratings. I was there over the weekend and the bagel I had was a step up from a frozen Lender's Bagel. They don't have a flat top to cook eggs so the eggs look like something from McDonald's. I won't be back. Don't say you weren't warned!

Nice local spot to grab a smoothie, bagel sandwich, coffee, and maybe some ice cream. Everything here is good, but not spectacular. I strongly recommend the rosemary salt bagel. It is doughy perfection. The interior is cozy, and definitely feels like Ithaca.