Best Cookie Shop New York: reviews

No clue what any of the other food tastes like but holy moly is that chocolate chip cookie mind blowing! Best cookie I’ve ever had

Ordered this as a gift and the recipient loved the Italian cookies. Very pleased with the quality and prompt shipment.

Amazing peanut butter cup cookie! So soft, and warm - right from the oven

Ordered a 3D cake for $120 and wasn’t overly impressed. It was to serve 10 people, in which it was definitely more than enough. Only problem is, it was...

I love their frozen yogurt, but the owner is such a sweetheart. She's honestly so kind I love seeing her everytime I come here

Love these cookies, especially the "cookies and cream" cookie. They are huge!

Just moved to Brooklyn. First time trying today. I’m supposed to be going on a diet. Not sure how that is going to be possible because that pumpkin...

Awesome place for everybody.it's like candy castle.whatever you need you can find in here.

Hospitality Hospitality at its finest. Hospitality with all its powerful promises of happiness. Hospitality and kindness the Algerian way. Hospitality...

I love crumble. My Monday night always culminates with an order of cookies and it has been the best way to start my week!

Five stars for friendliness. Four stars for presentation. Whenever I go there’s no cupcakes. Plus no ice cream. Please bring it back!

Awesome. Smores cookie with perfect chew, great sweet/salty balance. Dagel was perfect, the dough was nice and moist, filling flavorful and not...

Next door to one of the best pizzerias in nyc (Louie and Ernies). Best place to grab dessert. Staff is friendly, and delicious. You have a small table...

I've been dreaming of coming here FOREVER and I finally made it happen! Even though it's freezing outside (-12C), I braved the cold to try...

Delicious cookies in a tiny little shop. If you don't love these cookies, you just plain don't like cookies. Always served warm and soft...

Very rude staff! I walked in today and they didn't even acknowledge us or said hello. Looked like they didn't want to be there. We just...

Phenomenal and affordable warm cookies in a small, late night, carry out location. The location is not accessible as patrons must climb ~five stairs...

I came here with my family and got a 3 cookies and 3 drinks. Two out of the three cookies were disgusting between the lack of flavor and the texture...