Cosimo's, Newburgh NY

Exelent the food was delicious!
We eve have a pizza, some entres and dessert. My plate was Fra Dablo.

Visited Cosimos for the first time in many years. Was always a favorite of mine before my relocation. They have not skipped a beat! Food and service continue to be top notch

Family and I went out for a birthday dinner. The entrees were great. The service was ok. Unfortunately, we ordered creme brulee for dessert not realizing that they put a shot of some kind of strong alcohol on it. My 13yr old tried their's first and complained. I couldn't eat mine either. Thankfully, they took my child's away and got her a different one. Wish they have us a heads up about it. Especially before serving it to a minor.

Handled a group of 13 with no problem but doesn't do separate checks. Food was great. Hookups for electric cars is available.

Fantastic food, welcoming staff and a nice atmosphere make for a time that won't disappoint

Great service, amazing food! Couldn't find the kids menu on the website but they do have one.

Food is quick and reasonably priced. Never had a bad meal and I would gladly pay 50% more for equivalent Italian food. Never had a bad appetizer, entre or desert

This is a local favorite with quality food and service. They have wood fired brick oven pizza and more traditional Italian dishes as well.

Just stopped for a salad, but it was great and a generous portion. Spot on service. Used their Tesla super chargers.

Walked in tonight at 9: 16 and was told we can’t be seated, online the restaurant says it closes at 10pm. When I mentioned the owners name Nicholas who I know personally they than said the website has the wrong hours. They did not even allow us to place an order to go. Unreal. Never will I come back sorry Nick.

Amazing wood fired pizza. I had the fennel sausage and the flavours were just spot on. Sauces and fresh mozzarella made daily on site. Prices were very reasonable. Definitely worth a visit.

Atmosphere and service were exceptional. Steak salad was not good but two of the four in our party were impressed with their meals.watermelon habanero margherita was a hit!

Warm service and delicious eats.

Even with a funky glass, the overall experience at Cosimo's was delightful. What are the odds of having the only dirty cup out of five glasses? Regardless, the waiter was quick and apologetic about the situation.

The cleanliness in general was far better than our previous restaurant blunder- just read the prior post regarding P & G's in Newpaltz, NY. The bathrooms at Cosimo's were clean and had fragrant soap. The extra attention to hygiene was appreciated. Unlike the other restaurant, the customer service here was welcoming and the water staff wore face masks. The energy was far more comfortable than our previous restaurant blunder. Further, our waiter was attentive and responsive towards the party's allergy concerns.

I thoroughly enjoyed my eggplant and goat cheese sandwich. The ginger sald dressing was also pleasant. The party equally enjoyed their meal; from the spicy chicken fuscilli to eggplant parmigiano, the freshness and quality of the food were well received.

Overall, thank you Cosimo's for making our Father's birthday better.

BLT pizza and Greek salad. Patio dining while charging our Tesla at a super charger in the parking lot. Win Win.

1st time experience. Beautiful environment. Excellent Service. Delicious food. I'll be back the next time I'm in the area!

Had my rehearsal dinner here and this is a classic Italian restaurant with excellent service and one of the best places to rent a private room for Anniversary, Wedding, Graduation, etc in the area. Decent price for the quality of service. Solid, absolutely classic Italian and Italian American dishes. Good wine.