Cowfish, Hampton Bays NY

Don’t EVER work here! The managers treat you terribly. They will write you up For even being a minute late. It’s like they want their employees for 2 months than give up on you. They fired me for a walkout which I have no control over. The GM Paul. Was nice at the start but favors employees and that clearly shows. 1/10 work management.

Setting was gorgeous, food was good. Had so many different servers and didn't seem to have a designated person handling our table, which was a little unsettling.friendly and professionally and efficient, though

Beautiful scenery and outdoor backdrop, love the kids pirate ship, that was a huge hit and kept kids entertained. Food was delicious, definitely recommend!

The waitstaff were very snotty and upedy. When I came here with my mom, they said we needed a reservation to sit downstairs, but the dining room was nearly half full. They said we could sit upstairs in the bar lounge area, when going into the sun room one of the waiters was very snippy in asking where we were going (um, eating) he said it wasn’t available yet there were only two tables occupied. So we went to sit in the bar area and three waitstaff passed us by. No-one offered water, menus or even “ someone will be with you shortly due to a staff shortage” We sat there for nearly twenty minutes before a waitress brought us lukewarm water and a very spars and way over priced menu. Looking through the slim pickens with a 14oz steak and the 28 dollar fish and salmon we both decided to leave. The only reason I gave this anything more than a -50 ans gave it. 2 was the interior and outside landscape

Best location, best service, best food… We eat here all the time! We just had a party of 12 today and we were graciously accommodated. Best to make a reservation. If you get a chance to go for brunch, the spicy Nashville Fried Chicken is amazing. You really can’t go wrong with any appetizer or entree, not to mention the cocktails!

Food was great, a bit pricey for me, but it was a nice treat. It was on the water do big plus. Our waiter was delightful. Overall great evening

Thought I would write a little something since it was such a nice event that the bride and groom planned. Everything went very well, from the ceremony outside to apps, dinner, dessert and drinks. Thank you to the staff at Cowfish for being so efficient, accommodating and helpful. It was a joyous occasion which was enhanced by the ambiance and delicious meals! Thank You from the Hunter and Bogil families

18 Nov. 2021,
We had the pleasure of dining at Cowfish, last night. My first visit to your restaurant. My grandson requested that we dine here.
We had amost delightful young lady as our server, her name was Sophie.
When we were leaving I needed directions to 'Sunrise Highway' saddly I did not inquire the name of the young woman who gave them to me. She took the time to actually write them out for me, as I advised her I was not at all familar with the area.
In addition to the very lovely staff, the food was " DELICIOUS".

Very expensive small portions. Service was slow. Scallops were delicious though. Banana cream pie was very good my husband said

Always fun to experience Cowfish and it's sister restaurant Rhumba. Good food and nice atmosphere

One can never go wrong at this restaurant.
I love the service, views, and the food is over the top!

Great food, love the tuna and brussel sprouts, good cocktails, and a fabulous view from the upstairs bar.

My wife and I had bloody Mary's the olives were great. We had appetizers including spinach dip and chips, brussle sprouts, and clam chowder. The Brussel sprouts mustard sauce was a bit strong for our taste, but still very tasty. Dip was great and soup was excellent. I had the flounder, great choice and my wife had the tuna, " coconut rice was exceptional". All and all great experience and the service was great too. Signing off CIA chef Thomas Agunzo. My children liked the ship outside.

Staff is had the cowboy burger and Mahi tuna sandwiches along with a stuffed mushrooms w/ lobster. All excellent choices

Food was amazing and the location is beautiful! Our waitress was so friendly and so attentive. Thank you for a wonderful experience, definitely coming back!