Custom Cakes NYC Inc.

This is my 4th cake from this place and they never disappoint!
The cake taste better each time,
The design are flawless.
Highly recommend it!

Amazing! Ty Custom Cakes for the incredible birthday cake for my "better half" (see pics)

I had some high expectations because I've seen and heard great things, but now I've personally been blessed.

Maricor had patience with me as I sorted through flavor and special topping options. I changed my mind several times. I honestly got to the point where I just put her in charge as the expert. And voila! Look at this cake. And on the inside.such delicious cake and strawberry cream! Everyone enjoyed it and there was so much of it. 4 layers! Can't thank you enough Custom Cakes Inc!

Went for a cake tasting for a wedding cake and it was awful. The cake samples looked like it was just thrown together and it was pretty bad. The chocolate cake was tolerable and so was the red velvet but I could have made better cake from a boxed mix. The other 2 slices I had was not good at all. They were so bad I took one bite and was forgot what flavor I just ate. I'm giving it 2 stars Because the lady working there seemed very sweet and the Cake that she was working on looked very pretty from where I was seated. I wanted to like this place but I just couldn't.im so sorry.

First time ordering from here and will not be the last. Prices are reasonable, cakes look great but tastes even better! A lot of variety of flavors, I ordered a vanilla cake with oreo filling. AMAZING! Thank you!

Amazing creations, delicious flavors and so easy to work with, cannot recommend this place enough for your custom cake needs.

Update: 6.18.22
We have contracted with this place for years-since our wedding cake and they have not disappointed. Most recently did my son’s 8th bday cake (Roblox theme) and it came out great! Tasted amazing and was a hit with the other parents. Will continue to use her for future cakes.

Previous Review:
So we have worked with this place 4 times. And twice they have been great and twice they have been ok. Our wedding cake was amazing and perfect. It had everything that we wanted in a cake. For my son's baby shower we we're going for a beach theme and that was ok. I guess my expectations were kind of high because of how the wedding cake turned out. Then for my son's 1st bday party I wanted cupcakes with something from the Incredibles. They came up with printed edible sheets on top of the icing. And then recently for my son's 4th bday party we asked for a lightning McQueen Cake. While cartoony we didn't have crazy high expectations and my son loved the toy on top of the cake.

Everything that was made for us tasted great. Can't complain about the taste. And price is very reasonable. I just know now that if we something fancy like a wedding cake to definitely come here.

Amazing cupcakes and cake. Not only was it delicious but they looked amazing. Thank you for making my graduation even more special with this cake.

Last year we ordered the ice cream cake when our baby turned 2. Taste and design were incredible. This year I’ll be ordering again for my two kids. Great work!

Amazing! Give them a picture and they will deliver! I was so amazed by the product I got. Not only was it beautiful on the outside but delicious on the inside. I got the chocolate with vanilla and Oreo filling. Customer service was great too. Will definitely be stopping by again!

Absolutely amazing. I ordered a custom cake for my boyfriends retirement and it exceeded my expectations. Its was beautiful. And in only 4 days time Maria made it happen. It was the talk of the party. I can't thank them enough. And it was yummy. Thank u. I will definitely use them for every special occasion

The cake me amazing. Our son is autistic and we weren't sure what to get but since he loves cocomelon we went ahead and chose that and it was everything to us. Thank you so much. The State the details is exactly like we wanted.

I’ve had the true pleasure of getting two fabulous cakes from Maricor. So talented and pleasant. She never fails on the vision. How exciting to see the finished product. The cakes were ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! Thank you so much! I am guilty of needing a cake last minute, I’ll do better Maricor, promise lol! Special thank you to her husband who stayed with me for 2 hours (YIKES!) when I locked myself out of my car with the cake inside! I was frantic but the cake survived! I recommend this bakery anytime. You will not be disappointed!

It was such a beautiful cake inside out, taste amazing, everyone at the party was talking about how great it tasted, I will be ordering again, keep up the good work she is such a nice person, overall experience just beyond great

Love this place only been here 3 times for 3 different cakes and they all was beautiful and short notice never disappoints me

Maricor has blessed us with such a beautiful, textured cake. Everyone at our reception loved the fresh strawberry filling in our vanilla wedding cake. Thank you for making our last minute, intimate wedding such a success.

I ordered a strawberry shortcake from them, which was fantastic! A 10! I will be back. Thanks!

Highly recommend! After searching for an authentic and trustworthy baker a week before my mother’s birthday, I finally found one worthy of the price and the results were fantastic. Aside from the exceptional customer service and interpersonal skills, My baker was patient, thoughtful, gave recommendations and gave me exactly what I asked for. Very last minute, I needed a custom design birthday cake for my mother’s birthday (08/08) and custom cakes NYC made it happen in two days. Everyone including myself enjoyed it! Will do business with them again. What did I order exact? A vanilla buttercream cake with fresh strawberries, with a fondant pink marble background design with edible butterflies and edible small flowers. “ it’s leo season, happy 42nd birthday “ in script. Along with the edible Leo zodiac picture. Slices 20 pieces of cake.

Thank you sooo much you made my parents 37th anniversary special the cake was simply perfect I strongly recommend this place for all your events she's simply the best

I am so amazed how the cake turn out to be exactly I how picture it. I am so impressed of her work and I will definitely come back again for another custom cake. Every penny was worth it. She’s very nice and pleasant to deal with. She responded on me via text so quickly. Excellent customer service and very professional!