Eddie's Pizza, New Hyde Park NY

I've been eating pizza here since high school 30 plus years ago and it's even better now!

Great food, old school service, classic mixed drinks, throwback atmosphere. Like time traveling. I have been coming here for years now. The vibe and food never disappoint.

Classic decor, just like I remember it from the 1970's.but don't let that fool you at all!
Food is some of the best. EVER.
Barpie is a must, potato and egg hero, baked clams.so many choices, you can't go wrong, either.

Food, service and staff are great.
Rated one of the best pizza places on Long Island.

Got the mussels dinner entree tonight, and it was amazing. Honestly, it's the best mussels I've ever had. Cleaned right! Everyone enjoyed their dinners tonight, and the waitress is amazing. I don't know her name, but she's a gorgeous blonde! Thanks for a great experience!

I’ve been coming in this place since I’m a child. I’m 56 years old now. My mother was a waitress here and was friends with the family that owned it. The pizza in this place is awesome. The rest of the food is just as good. The prices are beyond reasonable. The staff is always friendly. The food is always awesome. I would recommend this place to anyone.

Been going to Eddys over 45 years / many memories
Always the same. No change in menu … I think it can use a facelift…. But still going there and still living Eddys. Thank you ….

EDDIES is the best. Have eaten inside/Taken out. Bar Pie’s a specialty. Many other choices. DELICIOUS. Best treat on Long Island. Go go go

VERY thin pizza. Sauce was okay, pizza was not bad. I guess it's not the style we prefer. It wasn't the worst, though.

After all this time there is still no other bar pie like Eddie’s. Atmosphere is what one would expect from a local bar but the food is consistently solid. I only wish they would bring back their food truck!

Excellent food and service in a very downplayed atmosphere. Go for the best thin crust pizza anywhere.

Pizza was amazing, Staff was super friendly and helpful. Definitely reccomend a visit if you're looking for a good thin crust.

I dont know what happened to this place but.the service was awful and the food was overpriced garbage. Only 4 baked clams for 12.95 and not even whole clams in them.

This is the place I've been going to for almost 40 years. It's as good now, as it has ever been. There's tissues, and then there's Kleenex. Theres sports cars, and then there's the Corvette. There's pizza, and then there is Eddie's Bar Pies. Hands down, the best in NY.

Sorry all you Eddie's Pizza fans, we did not care for the cracker crust pizza. Salad was fair. Wait staff good.

One of the best pizzas on long Island. House salad delicious as well. Never a bad meal here.

Eat at the bar. Service was GREAT! Team environment demonstrated. Gentleman bartender was friendly, quick and a good conversationalist. Food was GREAT! BEST flat crust pizza with veal diablo sauce I have ever eaten in this style pizza. Top it up to your liking. I did. I also had an amazing grilled chicken hero with the works. Dine in or carry out, it is well worth checking this place out.

Ordered a 2 pizzas for takeout. I saw thin crust but did not expect it to be like a cracker crust. It was alright pizza, but just not my style.

Classic spot on LI. Been going for ages and always love it. Favorite bar pie style and pizza in general.