F Rozzo & Sons, New York NY

This place is just magnificent, fresh quality fish and a service like no other! Matt is the guy behind the counter who helped me out and he was just phenomenal! I must have asked him over 50 questions and he answered every single question while giving me a little fact about the fish or where its from. Overall great experience, as someone who has social anxiety I found this interaction very helpful, encouraging me to come back and keep engaging and buying fish! Thank you to Rozzo and sons for the great fish! And thank you Matt for being kind and patient while providing great service. GO CHECK THEM OUT!

Came to this place following great reviews and was deeply disappointed. I got 24 oysters and 2 branzinos. I specifically asked whether they check the oyster, as they do in other places, before putting them in the bag and was reassured that “they all good”. After I shucked the oyster the same day and had to throw away at least half of them b/o the look and smell. I tried to cook the fish the next day, but the smell was unbearable, so it went into the trash as well. Such a disappointment!