NEAREVIEW.COM

Flatbush Bagel, Brooklyn NY

Address 557 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Phone (718) 469-5700
Hours 6:00am-3:00pm
Website order.online/store/flatbush-bagels-brooklyn-24344205
Categories Bagel Shop
Rating 2.5 17 reviews
Nearest branches
Clove Road Bagels — 1300 Clove Rd, Staten Island, NY, United States
Briarcliff Bagels & More — 549 N State Rd, Briarcliff Manor, NY, United States
Similar companies nearby
Bagels N’ More — 4305 14th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
Dunkin' — 383 Court St, Brooklyn, NY
Bagels By the Park — 323 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY, United States
Wheated — 905 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY, United States

Flatbush Bagel reviews

17
Sort by: date highest rated lowest rated most helpful
Heidi
November 18, 2023 5:19 am

Bagels are great and customer service is excellent! Love coming here before work to grab breakfast and coffee:)

Holly
October 31, 2023 4:50 am

Fun and busy bagel shop with Delicious bagels, great juice in the fridge, and the creamiest vegan cream cheese I've ever found! Highly recommend if you're in the area!

Anne
October 29, 2023 1:47 am

Most disrespectful man at the cash register, yelling at women and making fun of customers. Never stepping inside this place again. EXTREMELY POOR SERVICE.

Lea
October 17, 2023 11:17 am

Very middle of the road. Not the most flavorful youll get. I can see tourists or transplants calling this amazing but there are delis in the area with better tasting, cheaper and more filling bagels

Zana
September 21, 2023 1:24 pm

There lox sandwich is delicious, BUT this morning I bought a $7 bagel with cream cheese and bacon. They put a pound of cold cream cheese, the bacon was very underdone, & bagel tasted like it was toasted for 2 seconds. This was the worst breakfast sandwich I have ever had from there. I would go back and get my money, but I’m already running late for work as is.

The guy making my sandwich was nice but the cashier is always a little passive aggressive, so I try not to bother her too much for anything extra smh this bagel was not worth $7. I legit could have gotten this same bagel in the corner store for $5 and it would have tasted better than this.

Michael
September 20, 2023 1:02 pm

My partner and I live in the neighborhood and we had heard good things about this establishment and were very excited to try a bagel from here. Our excitement turned into irritation when not only we got the wrong order, but the staff member who picked up the phone refused to take any accountability for the mistake, placing the full blame on Grubhub while being extremely dismissive and disrespectful to us.

BUYER BEWARE, there are so many other fine places to eat.

Vic
August 24, 2023 2:31 pm

They are very cheap and confusing here and there’s been a couple instances where I get berated for paying less than what I apparently owe even though they are the ones making my order and charging me.

The most recent time I went there:

I order turkey and cheese on a croissant, which is $6.50 at PLG nearby. I get to the register and pay like $7.50. So far so good. Then I’m waiting for my order as I’ve already paid $7.50. The lady at the register then calls me and has the order and she says oh this is a sandwich which is $12.99 and berates me for paying $7.50 even though she’s the one that charged me…like? I didn’t want a big sandwich and I didn’t make the actual order so like I’m very confused at this point. Overall they are cheap and I’d rather go to PLG where I know exactly what I’m ordering and what I’m paying for.

travis
July 24, 2023 9:53 pm

It's better than most corner stores, but it's trash compared to other bagel shops.like really trash. Either most of the ratings are fake, the people in that area haven't eaten good bagels, or they just have extremely low standards because I really doubt it's just a coincidence that most other bagel shops I've been to just taste better.

Chase
July 21, 2023 11:28 am

It's such a love hate relationship with this place. The bagels are great but for how much you charge STOP BEING SO CHEAP!

How much extra you charge me for vegetable cream cheese and then barely put any on? It is outrageously expensive and they are cheap. The worst combination.

Maya
July 20, 2023 1:20 am

Do with this picture what you will. No cream cheese. No onions. Just lox Lmaoo I forgot to take a pic of the BEC but yeahhh. 1 star.

Andre
July 06, 2023 4:53 pm

Straight disappointment. Ordered a bacon egg n cheese and there was hardly any bacon and it was extremely under cooked. (wish I could share a picture)
This place has gone downhill from when they first opened. Won't waist my money again!

Jade
June 17, 2023 12:22 am

Great variety of bagels and cream cheeses, as well as other things. Great coffee and friendly staff.

Akilah
June 11, 2023 3:24 pm

Not great, not terrible. Got a sesame bagel with scallion cream cheese. Bagel was good, cream cheese was definitely not fresh.

mike
May 31, 2023 10:38 pm

A recent visit to Flatbush Bagel made a lasting impression on me. I absolutely love getting my everything bagel there & coffee. They have a great staff working there. Very courteous & kind. Very fair prices as well. Highly recommend.

vicki
May 17, 2023 2:10 am

Love the place love the bagels and vegetables cream cheese staff is professional and friendly place is always clean.

Lee
May 16, 2023 9:22 am

I ordered from here many times but today I received the wrong order and when I called to see if they could fix it the guy who answered was extremely rude saying it’s no way they messed up my order and that I ordered the wrong item…. Why in the hell would I order something that I don’t eat? He wasn’t even listening he just saying ma’am it’s your fault smh

Lonny
May 13, 2023 8:16 am

Thieves. $15 for the most depressing bagel with CC and lox. Maybe 2 slices of lox? Yet all the hipsters in the area will happily cough it up. Very upsetting to see.

Add review