Garlic, New York NY

Great local pizza restaurant. The Buffalo slice is good but could use some blue cheese. Great hours and good personal pie options as well.

I've been coming here for several days now and I'm interested for everything they have to serve

Pizza must be good I suppose. Everyone around me really enjoyed their pizza. But they let me use their restroom when I most needed it. 5 on 5 easily hands down.

BEST PIZZA I'VE EVER HAD! If you come to NYC, please take the time to eat here, you won't regret it.

I came to eat here on the day my son was having surgery at nyu langone. The pizza was amazing! They really made my day on a sad day! Cant wait to go back!

I have to write this review while I am still here because this pizza was banging. NYC finest! Some really delicious options to pick from. We did 4 of the options available and shared and they were all devoured.try out they cocktails to go, Mango and Sangria were tasty and alcohol heavy 1st time here and I will definately make this my pizza stop when I am around and in the mood for some slices. If you are trying to make up your mind where to go, this is the place, thank me later.

I might as well just order a side of cheese and a side of bread cause that’s how the pizza gets delivered, pizza on one side of the box and the crust on the other.
But, it tastes good.

Fernanado (pizza maker) is absolutely the most hospitable, courtious, clean and friendly. He know's how to cook an amazing pie and never out of my ultimate fav buffalo ranch chicken. You cannot go wrong with any slice you ge. My experience gets better with each visit at Garlic. I typically go for a slice/salad 2-3x weekly.
Thanks Garlic!: -D

This place is a step up from your typical walk in pizza joint. They're not greasy or bland. Very flavorful square slices, slightly more doughy (as you'd expect from a square slice). I've also gotten meatball parm subs from here and they're good.

Excellent pizza! Open very late with welcoming staff. Must try if you're in the lower east side!

Yum! Here on vacation and this is the best! Recommend BBQ chicken and heroes! They made one today they don't have a name for and it was amazing!

Horrible delivery time! Never got my pizza in the course of 3 HOURS! Even after repeated phone calls and reassurances that it was "on its way". Finally had to cancel the order. DO NOT ORDER FROM HERE!

Not quite "NY" pizza but it was an interesting change of pace. Neat bar in the back for a casual drink, also a pretty great outdoor patio that is like a hidden gem.

This is my go-to pizza joint in the neighborhood. They focus on a few pies and don't vary their flavors much, though the taste and speed of service is consistently good

The pizza is very good, can't go wrong with any of the slides here. They have a sports bar in the back too

Me and my family wandered in while site seeing and cant say a bad thing about the place! Everyone we dealt with there was very friendly and they hooked us up with free refills.was a highlight of our trip to nyc

The options at this place are endless. I could come here every day for a year and not get the same thing twice!

Great atmosphere, delicious pizza and the drinks are strong, especially when the owner Joe makes them

Best take out pizza that I have had in Murray Hill and my go to for delivery (typically takes less than 30 min for me). You can also tell that they use high quality ingredients, especially the cheese.

Waiting FOREVER. $20 to sit around and wait 40+ mins after the estimated delivery. Called the restaurant and their excuse is they were "busy". No offer on partial refund or something on them. Definitely won't be ordering again with that type of treatment.