Gatsby On The Ocean, Wantagh NY

I attended a fantastic tasting event at the end of February. All of the food stations were excellent.
Sunday, my daughter had her wedding here, which was excellent, and came off without a hitch.

We had great birthday party here. Elyse did a fabulous job for 4 months of the planning. John was the host for the event.
Their entire staff was so attentive
Peaceful beautiful view of the Atlantic from every window.
Will use this venue again

I attended a party here in October 2023 and everything was fabulous! Food was delicious! Staff were great. Highly recommend.

I can't say enough great things about the Gatsby! What a beautiful place! I just had my daughter's Sweet 16 here this past weekend. It was absolutely awesome! Elyse, Heather and John were awesome every step of the way. The food was absolutely delicious and all of the workers were amazing! My guests are still raving about the party! I highly recommend The Gatsby for any affair!

I had my wedding reception at the Gatsby on October 1st. The venue is breathtaking. Heather was very accommodating and easy to work with. She as there every step of the way with me. Caitlyn the bridal attendant was there for everything I needed. I don't know what I would have done without her. John the maitre'd ran everything like a well oiled machine and made sure everyone was happy. Caitlyn and John even helped us load up our car at the end of the night. The rest of the staff worked so hard throughout the entire event but always with a smile. The food was absolutely delicious. I am so very glad that I picked the Gatsby for my wedding reception.

I attended my friend’s wedding reception at The Gatsby on Sunday.
It was wonderful! It’s such a beautiful venue and everyone was so attentive. The staff went over and above to make sure things were perfect and they were! Everything was terrific ; the venue, “the vibe” and the food! The golf cart ride added to the fun! I highly recommend The Gatsby.

I went to a wedding there yesterday, October 1,2023. I actually was there last year with the bride and groom looking at the venue the only thing I didn’t like was the floor I walked in there yesterday and the floor was absolutely beautiful. They changed it. It was a much needed change. Between the view, the bridal suite all the employees everything was excellent. The food was fantastic. The cocktails were find. Dessert was delicious. I highly recommend this place.

Was at an event, beautiful view, and sunset by the beach. I had chicken dinner with potato and asparagus. No complaints

We had our wedding reception at Gatsby and it was AMAZING! We worked with Heather who organized our wedding, and she was phenomenal. She helped us with everything before, and even after the wedding! We were also lucky enough to have John and Kaitlyn as our Maitre’d and bridal attendant, my family was thrilled at how special and well taken care of they felt during the whole party! Cocktails, dj, cake, and everything was to rave about. Another perk is that the whole grounds is beautiful and big so I didn’t have to go anywhere else to take my wedding portraits!

I was part of a wedding this past weekend and everything was perfect- from breakfast to dinner, the food was fantastic; servers and the maitre’d John went above and beyond to ensure everyone had a fantastic experience. The venue itself is unique and beautiful. A perfect wedding venue!

I had a wonderful afternoon lunch at Gatsby on the Ocean. The atmosphere, beautiful ocean view, and the food were nothing short of exceptional! A beautiful place to dine for amazing food! Make sure to order the bruschetta as well, you won’t be disappointed! 5/5 would recommend! I’ll be back, Gatsby!

Food was great, atmosphere was fun. I enjoyed my day. Will definitely come here again. I recommend this place.

Perfect location great food really nice staff from bartender to server’s warm courteous attentive go check it out for dinner

Gatsby On The Ocean is the PERFECT getaway! I arrived to the outdoor bar in the early evening seeking some much needed rest and relaxation. The weather and atmosphere were a perfect combination, and my bartender Ed made the entire experience! He is world class, and obliged all my requests for the unique island drinks I love and even created some new ones!
Gatsby’s is lucky to have Ed bartending and so was I! 5 + infinity stars!

It’s a 1st and last for me. The waitress comes, offers us drinks and bring the drinks, 15 minutes later. Then about 35 minutes later I had to ask the receptionist if there was a delay in ordering our food. So she goes and brings it to the attention of the “manager “. The waitress kept forgetting my kid soda after asking over 3 times. Customers were getting their food like within 20 minutes of getting there. We got served over an hour later. The waitress comes and says “ oh I thought you were only drinking “. So I ask myself why do we have Menus in front of us? Waiters usually ask the costumer if they want something to drink, and then come around and ask the costumer if they’re ready to order, but not in this case. Everything was delayed, the rice I order was hard. Definitely not coming back

Great view of beach, delicious lobster roll with butter and shrimp taco, nice staff, good DJ.cocktails were disappointing.overall a good experience.