Gino & Joe's Pizza, Clay NY

Thank you Julie you made my wife's day with suggesting the personal pan garlic pizza, then asking for extra toppings

Hands down the best pizza in town. Great sauce super cheesy. Thanks guys for Great customer service

The pizza was a disaster. Cut like a kindergartener cut it huge & tiny. Too much sauce, couldn't eat without a knife & fork. The peppers were horrible. Wasn't cooked enough either. Ended up tossing the rest of it. However, the fried ravioli that was great. Won't bother spending money there again.

The manager at this location was EXTREMELY rude and arrogant. My order was not correct (I spent $80!) and he told me that I needed to contact door dash. He told me that he had nothing to do with the order being incorrect when they made the food? He then hung up on me. The food was not even that good! If i could give them zero stars i would!

$10.36 for 2 slices and a drink? Your pizza is good but it's not that good. That's too much. Unfortunately I won't be coming back.

Whole Pizzas ordered should not be cheese pizzas prepared and cooked in the morning and then toppings added and reheated in the oven when you order them later in the day. I get doing slices at lunch like that. But not OK otherwise!

The bbq chicken pizza was popcorn chicken nuggets… it’s a NO for
Me. I want real chicken when I order bbq chicken pizza. Sad

I think something that a lot of pizza places lack is consistency; You never know if the pizza is going to be the same. This Gino and Joe's location is always consistently good. Will now be my go to pizza place.

They know me as " fat guy " as a joke and I gotta say this place doesn't disappoint. There garlic knots are the size of baseballs and amazing. But the pizza is addicting, I always get extra sauce on mine cause there sauce is awesome. Everything I've ordered from these guys is just delicious. I recently even got my mom hooked on them who loves there wings, garlic knots and if you haven't tried it but want a thick crust there sicilian style pizza, just amazing. When it comes to the staff, love em, everytime I show up I feel like im being welcomed into a friend or family members house I haven't seen in a while. As someone whos big on pizza I've been all over liverpool, Syracuse, and surrounding areas, this is the best

Ordered online: pepperoni pizza, sampler appetizer, fettuccine Alfredo. All of these things were options on their online menu. Was pleased when the driver pulled up in 30 minutes, except they did not bring the pizza or Alfredo. The driver went back to get the pizza and I called when I saw they put riggies or some other type of pasta dish with my order instead. Was told they did not have Alfredo and I requested a refund. THEY DO NOT GIVE REFUNDS. So you are left paying for whatever they decide to give you. The driver did return with the pizza 35 minutes later. I spoke to a manager today and was told they had Alfredo sauce, just not fettuccine pasta, yet riggies were sent instead of just putting the ordered sauce on whatever pasta. Again I was told that they can not give refunds and was given a credit I won't use, as I won't be ordering again because now it's just too many times where things have been wrong and they respond with a credit for next time. No thank you. It is unfortunate that the customers don't matter because their food is really good. Also as I see on all negative reviews the person controlling their profile is hostile and belittling to any negative comments, so I will look forward to your excuses and deflection of responsibility.

Most of the pizza is great. I like the eggplant parmigiana one. I hate hate hate that any of the specialty pizzas with chicken use chicken nuggets. Like breaded, spongy, "chicken" nuggets. I feel like if I am shelling out for a specialty pizza like their expensive deep dish chicken vodka one, it should have grilled chicken breast. Not cubed nuggets. Hence the 3 stars. Avoid any chicken pizzas imo.

I stopped at Gino and Joe’s (in Clay) today, to pick up a small salad with grilled chicken. It was the best decision I could have made! The chicken was grilled to perfection, all of the salad ingredients were so FRESH, right down to the white (not brown) mushrooms! When I want a salad from now on, I’ll be stopping at Gino and Joe’s! BTW, the young woman putting the salad together was most friendly and accommodating! Thank you!

Ordered two meal items and both were technically right, cutlet sandwich and lasagna, but completely wrong. Sandwich was ordered toasted with spinach and mozzarella, came cold with LTO. Lasagna was a sheet of pasta, just meat, a sheet of pasta a ton of cheese and a sheet of pasta. Nothing tasted too great aside from the side salad and bread.

Been a very long time since I've been to Gino and Joe's but boy let me tell you this was the best calzone I've had many many decades love you guys