GoodFellas of l.i.c, Queens NY

Goodfellas is always appreciated in any neighborhood in NY. They do pizza, and they do it well! Small storefront, but big cheese slices, and very fresh pies coming out of the oven. Friendly window counter service, and the menu is outside, easy to view! A bunch of chairs and tables outfront for enjoying your pizza right away!

Great pizza. Was in town from Texas and I have to say some of the best pizza I've had. The bacon chicken ranch pizza was my favorite. Great group of people running it also. I would highly recommend this place.

I really REALLY love this pizza.
The owner is a nice guy who takes a lot of pride in his business - it shows.

Personally, it’s my favorite in LIC for a good NY slice (and garlic knots -with sauce)

Great pizza, super cheap they have a nice 2 slices plus a soda for 5$. Doesn’t get better than that

This is my go-to place in the area for an afternoon snack. They got great deals for pizza, and it taste amazing.

Got a cheese and margarita slice and it just really hits the spot.

They also have a special of 2 cheese slices and a can of soda for $5 which I will go back for

Great food, pizza, wings etc.contactless for corona. Great spot if you’re in the area or looking for a bite.

If you go to this side of NYC you can try probably one of the best pizzas in town. Like an hidden gem pizzas here are heavenly good. You can go for the 5 dollar deal or for a whole pizza but be sure to have someone to share it with otherwise you will be facing a challenging food coma.

The white pizza was outstanding! The pasta was great too but left something to be desired. My sister lives near here and orders relatively often not just because of the location but because of the awesomeness.

Stayed at Boro hotel near by Goodfellas. Got 2 slices and garlic bread to go. Everything were very very good! Don’t let the humble place and the low price fool you. They make excellent pizza! Will definitely stop by again the next time I am in town.

Just called for an order and was advised they "Have No one to cook, no chef on site". Never even heard of that! Place opens and closes whenever it wants too. Zero consistency. Order elsewhere!

As a pizza chef for a number of years these guys have it perfect! The crust is crackerjack perfect with a little doughy just to make it right, not too much purée in the sauce very little! You can taste the homemade sauce. My guess made every few days. The tomatoes are not too salty but tasty and perfect. Some people cover up bad crust and sauce with extra cheese, not these guys, because they are Goodfellas! Definitely worth the stop! 5/5 stars

Best pizza and Heros in the area.
Have they closed the past few days I have gone there for lunch and dinner they haven't been open?

Love this place. 2 regular slices and a sode for 5 bucks can't be beat. Plus is its walking distance from work

Been coming to this pizza shop since middle school. Best pizza in LIC. Of you’re ever here make sure you stop by best pizza in the city.

Amazing staff, homey/chill environment, and great pizza. What more can you ask for? I’m a pleased New Yorker fo’ sho.

Great pizzeria! The pizza was delicious and the staff is very friendly! I highly recommand this place!

Great little local pizza shop. Very small only a couple bar stools and a table or 2 outside. The pizza is so good! We actually ate there once and got take out another night. Loved it. Wish I could get their pizza all of the time.

I ordered Sicilian and Chicken slices. The Sicilian was the dryest I've ever had. The chicken was almost all bread, topped with a little sauce, cheese and chicken. Too much bread for me. As a co-worker said, "They make sandwiches, not pizza. "

Awesome slice of pizza in LIC. I had the meat lover's and a slice of cheese. Both were excellent. The crust, the toppings, and general classic NY style pizza is a must if you're in the area. Definitely gonna be hitting it up regularly.