Gus's Restaurant & Tavern, New Windsor NY

Friendly and attentive service. Nice atmosphere. My kalbshaxe was excellent, the Spätzle and Red cabbage served with it was disappointing. Apple strudel for dessert was delicious and the coffee was good.

We have come here for decades. Consistently wonderful food, people, service and portion.
Family celebrations to birthday and 50 th wedding anniversary parties.
Gus’s holds a place near and dear to our hearts.

Excellent service, food was delicious. We had escargot, Spaetzle and gravy, prime rib, carrots cake. All were perfect.

We all left satisfied. Three of us had steak and we were all very satisfied. One person had fish and it was very good. We will definitely go there again soon.

My fiance and I enjoy going to Gus'. The food is wonderful and the service is great. They make you feel at home. We recently had a baby and went to dinner at Gus' and we were able to sit in our own little area. It was very quaint. Will definitely be regular customers there.

Delicious schnitzel and hoffbrau beer on tap. The only reason it's not 5 stars is that they don't serve German style pretzels

Then come in here for a minute years since my children are small that are now grown hasn't changed one bit I mean food and fair when they make the cream of mushroom soup a roast beef is always rare in sliced thin

I was curious about trying this place after moving in right down the block. Boy was I disappointed. I'm not even sure how this place stays open after all these years because it is the worst German food I have ever tasted in my life. Clearly their time has long passed.

Gus has successfully owned + this establishment for over 40 years + for good reason! Uncompromising quality + authentic flavored German cuisine. Just when we thought we couldn't eat one more spaetzle + gravy, it was time for apple strudel We came as a bereavement group + left uplifted by the outstanding 'comfort food'!

I first ate at this restaurant about 25 years ago and the food was amazing! 25 years later, we decided to make the trip and were looking forward to another amazing dinner. Unfortunately, the dinner wasn't quite as amazing as I last remembered it. The food we had was all good, but not great. I don't know what happened after all these years, (maybe a different owner or chef) but it certainly wasn't worth more than 3 stars. The portions are decent, but don't expect to be taking home a doggy bag though. We had some mixed drinks, but they were way too strong to enjoy. That's what shots are for. We mentioned it to the waitress and she kindly apologized and removed it off the bill (which was very fair). We just played it safe and had beer instead. I remember the place having an old world charm. The decor was still the same but they tried to modernize it by adding colored LED lighting. It was so out of place. It just made it look cheap. It was like bedazzling antique furniture. For what it cost to eat here, I wouldn't recommend it when there are so many more great restaurants in Orange County with better than average food.

First time visitor but not the last. Debbie (our server) was great, food was delicious and the atmosphere was wonderful. Go check this place out.

I visit this restaurant from time to time! This is the best place to to have a good dinner. I visit this spot frequently. The cooking is great, the crew is friendly and the payment is affordable. I enjoy meeting in this restaurant over a tasty dinner.

Food didnt have any taste and when you said thank you to the waitress she said aha, no thank you at all. Very unprofessional.

The best Hungarian Goulash I've ever had! The salad my wife had was filling and did not skimp at all. The service was great and I can't wait to go back!
Great place for German fare, highly recommended.

Appetizers were pretty good, I highly recommend the pierogi. Can't say the same for the entrees, the wurst was dry and the veal schnitzel was really thick and chewy at parts.