Hearth, New York NY

Have always liked this place. Consistent over the years. Have been several times for dinner. Fabulous. Went last wknd for brunch. Savory and seasonal, great!

Went here for restaurant week! Our server Nigel was very kind and informed. The food was delicious - well thought out, portioned, balanced, creative, etc. Maybe the pizzocheri was a bit too heavy? But that could be subjective. Highly recommend the olive oil cake and the fish. Thank you for the lovely experience!

The service, food, and atmosphere were fantastic. I loved the restaurant and am looking to return.

We had a fantastic meal here. From the butter to the mains, everything was fantastic. Pasta dishes were deeply satisfying. The pricing to quantity ratio was a little off. $17 for four small carrots seems unnecessarily and somewhat insultingly petite. That said, the atmosphere was cozy, not too loud with friendly service. Would return.

It took us a minute to get seated, but that was because other tables refused to get up! The wait staff generously gave us some bubbly to tide us over in the meantime.

I have never had red sauce so good. Highly recommend the meatballs!

I stopped by for breakfast menu and I’m definitely coming back to try out main dishes. This place has a twist of hidden kitchen secrets.

Great Italian restaurant with cozy vibes. The Macchroni and meatballs were amazing. Garlic bread was burnt but delicious. Hard to gauge the vibe of the servers as it alternated between annoyed to playful to rude.

Kind of odd experience. Took an hour and a half to get our food. Food was so good, but I’m so disappointed with our experience. We kept asking how much longer our food would take, we asked for more bread because we were starving. They acted like it was a big deal for comping our extra bread, when they really should have comped our drinks…. Overall good food, but not sure I’ll be back because of service

This is a great place for groups and also intimate dates. It's a spacious area with a cozy vibe. The staff were very friendly and knowledgeable. I came here with 3 friends and we all enjoyed our food. Perfect portion sizes. It's a bit on the pricey side, but given everything I mentioned, it's worth it.

One of the best places I’ve ever eaten. I’m a good blogger, I eat… a lot. This place was incredible. As well as the cocktails. Truly one of my absolute favorite places and will definitely be back when we visit NYC again!

It is a really nice restaurant with a lot of tables. We came on Saturday night, and it was pleasantly busy. The waitress was super nice. The food was good, but I felt like the vegetable dishes were extremely small. I ordered the fish with two sides, and it came with a tiny piece of fennel and mostly onion for $36. The beetroot dish was also very small for $19. We were recommended to order bread. I didn’t want to fill up with bread.

Cocktails and Food were excellent (and healthy).
Server was able to recommend really good wines.
Nice and chill atmosphere.
Will return 10/10.

We had a wonderful experience here. The room is beautiful and well put together. Our servers were friendly and straightforward. Cocktail list was inspired and we enjoyed a good round. We appreciated the sommelier to navigate the extensive wine list and landed a wonderful bottle with a grape varietal we’d never tried.
Food was all excellent as well. Shout out to the meat balls!

We went for brunch on a Sunday. The food was great. So tasty! Service was great too. Highly recommended!

I am not one to return to a restaurant when visiting New York. Hearth is the exception. I went in December and again this week. The service is amazing and the ambiance is warm and cozy. When you go order the garlic bread and the meatballs, it will not disappoint. We also ordered a pasta and got a great recommendation for wine. I highly recommend going to Hearth.

Great atmosphere and service! Upon entering, the staff was super friendly and the waiter was great at recommending us food and drinks. The food however was a let down. The garlic bread was very flavorful and I loved the lemon addition, however a majority of the bread was burnt. The meatballs, which we heard was a must, we're underwhelming to say the least. Lastly the pork ragu was pretty good. Loved the rosemary flavor with it! Overall just wish the quality of food was higher especially for the price point.

Seed-oil free restaurant! I am a fan of Hearth. Not only do they have a great selection of food from the menu, but awesome staff too. I’m glad I came here while visiting New York City for a long weekend. Thanks, Hearth!

Hearth is pricey. In THIS case I'd say, you get what you pay for. Nice people serving, good food, nice ambience. I'll go back.

I am going with three stars - it was actually a pretty good experience, but some of the members of our party really didn’t enjoy their meal - the burger and fish in particular. It’s a nice restaurant, but very pricey for what’s on the table. The service was just okay. Overall decent but not great.

Tasting menu with wine pairing is worth the price. An absolutely delightful meal with fantastic, flavorful courses and thoughtful drink pairings.

Update from over a year later and after renovations, the staff is still wonderful and attentive, the menu is still phenomenal, the atmosphere is so homey. Definitely recommend.