Hickory Hill Market, Windham NY

The cutest gas station / market I've ever seen! Has options for everyone, including gluten free! Food was great, space was super clean and cute. Great music too!

Nice gas station with welcoming cashiers. However the lady in charge of the receipts at the deli is rather condescending and borderline rude. And they got the order completely wrong

I absolutely LOVE this store! They have everything you could need in a town with absolutely nothing when you need it.lol. BUT, everytime i order a sandwich it always has turkey instead of ham. They still make the best subs in windham though and i wont complain but the 4 or of 6 times ive ordered honey maple ham they always give me honey maple turkey.otherwise NO complaints but this

Nice place to go shopping.
There is a little bit of everything.
Great selection of beers.
Good fresh pizzas and sandwiches. L
Eat-in area available.
Excellent staff, very friendly.

Great place has everything you need. However the hot sandwiches need a little work. Meatball was totally red inside without much taste. Chicken parm was cut in small pieces as opposed to one nice sized cutlet. They are very understaffed at night and wait times can be long

The food is good and but the cashiers taste better. This place is full of bangin girl and good food. A good stop for single men.

I never knew a place like this existed in Windham and I'm so glad that it does. They have almost everything you need here but best of all, they make fresh food and provide seating! My boyfriend and I tried the personal pizza (it's thin crust), sandwich and chicken noodle soup. The pizza and sandwich was made to order and absolutely delicious as was the soup.

My go to place from now on whenever I'm up in the mountains.

Have tried many types of coffee, sandwiches and pizza, and shopping experience is excellent! Prices are excellent!

Wood fired oven pizza was great! Pick your own toppings with many choices. Clean, well stocked store, walk in beer cooler, fresh salads, made to order sandwiches, Fresh produce, gourmet cheeses and pepperoni, even seared Ahi tuna strips in the freezer. Hand scooped ice cream as well as gourmet pints in freezer section. This is the new gold standard for “convenience” markets! The air pump is free, NICE TOUCH!

Most amazing gas station - country store I've ever been in. Fresh produce. Gluten free options, Excellent breakfast and lunch sandwich. Delicious brick oven pizza. I go there almost every day. The staff is doing great. Keep it up.

I love Hickory Hill Market! It's clean, the staff is very friendly and helpful. I go in there on a regular basis to get my morning cup of coffee - which I find very addicting and always piping hot! Now if only they sold the coffee in a box.

I had the food prep area make me a sandwich and it looked extremely delicious. The care and effort in its preparation was pleasant to watch. They use boar's head products.

Really friendly and helpful service and great prices and great food plus I walk right cross the street to go to the store can’t beat that keep up great work guys

It's hard to imagine a better local convenience market. Fresh produce, snacks, quality sandwiches and wood-fired personal pizzas. We had a mushroom pizza and salami provolone sandwich. Not quite 5 stars but they seem to be working out the links - there was coffee in the iced tea dispenser, the Danish was ordinary and there was some confusion about where to return trays. I expect 2 out of 3 of these will improve.