Best Ice Cream Shop New York: reviews

Excellent soft ice cream - many flavors that change monthly. Larger portions than most places. They also sell food. Pavilion with overhead heaters for...

Had lemon ice it was awful tasted like reconstituted lemon juice in the bottle terrible after taste very disappointed! Threw out most of it I should...

For about 8 bucks you can get this monstrosity of a cone! It WILL tire ur arm…. Good luck! You’ll love it! (Cash only, but has atm)

After photographing an engagement session at the Brooklyn Bridge, stopped for ice cream while heading to the subway. Its right next to the bridge...

Beautiful place with beautiful people and delicious food. The burgers are amazing: moist, favorable, just yum! The pies are beyond words and apple...

Amazing place, wonderful employees and great candy! I would recommend this place to anyone who's looking for good chocolate or any other candy.

Best Gelato Ever! Heaven in a bowl. I tried about 6 flavors and they were all amazing. Party of 4 and everyone loved their Gelato!

Honestly I thought this place was going to be OK and all about the social media pictures. After tasting the icecream though I can honestly say this...

Ice cream is delicious, I had vanilla ice cream and a waffle bowl, both wonderful. Food is OK, the tenders were fine and fries were just ok...

Fantastic pistachio, bacio, and Dulche de leche! The waffle cone was delicious! The tables outside are great for enjoying your gelato before going...

It’s okay - the lines are pretty long. It’s not traditional gelato - you’ll see bright colors and gelato piled high in the containers. Flavors are a bit...

Pretty good food, but I was definitely still hungry after a just under 10 dollar sandwich and drink. Great location and worth a stop!

The gelato is good! The space and the concept are great, and I’m sure the cakes are amazing. But they still have their no samples policy from 3 years...

Went for the first time after hiking. Had a soft serve pumpkin ice cream. The serving was enormous! The ice cream was creamy and delicious. The girl...

Small parking lot but normal for the area. Workers were quick and friendly. I tried the mint ice cream with carob chips. Good experience and a nice...

Fast ordering, fast service. Stuff is very attentive and friendly.
Ice cream is the best.

First time visiting this icecream shop. The icecream is pretty amazing. We got the PB signature Sundae and the PB Sundae both where amazing. Best...

Ice cream is always smooth and flavorful. Staff is nice even on the hottest of days.

First time getting pizza there (to go). Very good pizza at a reasonable price.

Best ice cream on the northfork with options for everyone. Only complaint is the parking. It's horrendous