Best Irish Pub New York: reviews, page 2

It was a fun time but they charged a 20% gratuity for all drinks even very simple ones
Burger was bad

The cocktails at this place are absolutely epic. Only downside is the location. It is super busy right outside the doors and outside seating needs a second...

There's so much historical significance. I recommend speaking to any regular local at this bar to get the history. Ask about the seat cushions at the...

Dropped in to watch a bit of Champions League and grab a beer whilst waiting for a cruise. Entertaining barmaid discussing some funny stories with the regulars...

The bartender is amazing, I will say that, but the manager is horrible. They claimed they lost my signed receipt, which was sitting at the table in the...

Prices were pretty good but the service was not. After our initial round we waited 20 mins for our waitress to order another but we couldn’t find her...

November 19,2022 update. Service so bad I ended up walking out. This place used to be crowded on Saturday night, but it wasn’t tonight. I can see why...

Love Phil Hughes! Great casual bar to hang out at on a Friday evening or for a game. The service is always excellent, beer selection is pretty decent...

The food was delicious. Emily was helpful. The music and atmosphere were delightful and the price was right. We can't wait to go back again.

Avoid at all costs. We saw on their website and online that they were serving pints on draft at Happy Hour from 4pm to 7pm all week. The four of us arrived...

Great whiskey spot! Good drinks. Very friendly bartenders! Good spot for solo sports watching or pre-gaming a night out with friends.

The brunch was good but the restaurant did not have a big selection of food to choose from. The service was excellent.

The bouncer was collecting $100 at the door from each group on 10/15/22.that cover was disgusting

Came here because we loved it years ago. Food was ok service was better. Typical bar food. We had the clam casserole app I recommend skipping it was...

Best staff in the world. Comparable to 11th Madison service. Waffles gives it 10 stars.

I felt if you weren't a regular, you were ignored. Ad a past patron, I was very put off by the service

Been going here for years. Food is decent, but not prepared as ordered. Have ordered medium rare and always get well done and chicken in salads and...

Poor costumer service, I don’t recommend this place to anyone, I don’t know how they pretended to get business treating costumers the way they do...

Very pleasant evening, very good service, our waiter spoke French, really nice Halloween decoration, very good beer and burgers (although I'm not...

Drinks 3/5 Atmosphere 2/5 Location 5/5 Staff 2/5 This is suppose to be the bar that inspired “how I met your mother” and as long as they can hold on to that...