Lilly's Craft and Kitchen, New York NY

An excellent place to eat, good atmosphere and bottomless brunch was wonderful. A must stop by while in NYC.

We made a reservation for 1pm and showed up at 12: 55 and they said it would be a few minutes. Then come 1: 05 they still hadn’t seated us, which was fine, but several people without reservations were seated. Then at 1: 10 they finally told us it would be a 20 minute wait. What was the point of making a reservation if we were going to have to wait a half hour? Anyway, we went to Empanada Mama a few blocks north and it was better.

Don’t expect that if you make a reservation they’ll actually reserve seats for you. What a wild concept.

Just had a delivery from them. And oh boy, it was the worst burger of my life! It has no taste whatsoever. The lettuce wasn’t fresh and was bitter. Absolutely disgusting.

Great wings and poutine! Wow. Excellent stuff. The beer selection is good too. Service was great (on a Wednesday night so who knows), and the atmosphere is nice. Definitely recommend it.

Honestly this place was not great. I guess we got seated in their overflow area (Molly Pitcher) so maybe that’s why but server was not attentive and food arrived less than warm after waiting a good while for it. The door does not close automatically and cigarette smoke kept wafting in along with a cool draft. Food tasted ok but nothing memorable.

Came around opening time and there were already a couple people inside. Would recommend making a reservation just in case!
Don’t like the stool seating, it’s very limiting especially now that people have coats and bags. They have limited hooks. Food was good, the French Toast Sticks were amazing! That’s my recommendation. We went during happy hour and spent around $180 (including tip) for 3 people with drinks and food. Decor is also very nice around the holidays.:)

Stopped by here for quick drinks because of the decorations for Halloween looked fun and festive, nice experience here, prices were so so but was served quickly

Somewhat below average for the Theater District and farther below par on average for the city in general. Starters came out fairly quickly, but the guacamole was bland and the pretzel was cold. The hot wings got a decent review from our party member who had them, but she admitted that she was judging them on the basis of extreme hunger. We ordered burgers all around - they took an exceptionally long time to come out and had flaws when they did - I had the standard burger and had ordered some toppings on the side - they were not 'on the side' but on the burger - the burger itself had no seasoning and was just not very good. My girlfriend asked for some honey-mustard and was pretty much ignored. One of our party ordered a turkey burger - menu specifies guac on the burger and it was not included. We did not enter complaints or send things back because we were heading to a show and it had already taken too long to get the food out. Too many other really good options right on the same block - we won't come back.

Second time here. Nice place. Attentive staff and good music though a tad loud. Great Happy Hour and guacamole!

Good environment, fun drinks and reasonable prices. Unfortunately the house frittata didn’t sit right with my stomach and made me?

Came with a friend from out-of-town since we live close. Our waitress Samantha was an absolute gem - she was hilarious and very attentive to a minor issue we had with one of our plates. Felt like we came out of the dinner with a new friend. Service is great!

My burger burnt but the stellar staff comped and worked to make it better. Kudos to them cause otherwise this review wouldn't be positive

More like 2.5 stars. Walked in for a late lunch (2: 30-ish). Atmosphere was pretty nice. Chill music. Nice front end staff. Friendly and helpful. Problem was the food. Ordered blackened chicken, soup and a side of mashed potatoes. First, presentation was respectable. But sandwich was clearly cooked earlier and then warmed (hard as a rock chicken). The soup looked nice but again chicken was previously grilled and the tossed in at last moment. Not sweet and tender but dry and boring. Mashed were actually good and showed a glimpse of what could have been.

Great atmosphere and great menu. You won’t be disappointed. Whether your team won or lost, you will find the good vibes you need to make it a great night. I highly recommend the happy hour (up until 8pm). The brussel sprouts, burgers, sliders and buffalo chicken tater tots are always a hit. The music, TV screens displaying the games and the wait staff are all A1. Special shout out to Moe and Izzy for being so attentive and helpful during the rush happy hour. Couldn’t have asked for a better time. 10/10.

Been visiting Lilly’s for a bit now, and I have to write this long overdue review.

Let’s start with my favorite dish; poutine. To effin die for! I’m not a Canadian or French so I don’t know “real” or “proper” poutine but at Lilly’s, you can’t go wrong!

The drinks; Perfection! Been to bars where the mojitos are ridiculously watered down, I love the fact that when you order a drink, you get a DRINK.the drinks do justice. Always.

The bartenders are friendly, the staff is attentive, and the crowds always right any time of day.

I love the fact that I can order ANYTHING off the menu and it’s always a banger. Always hits the spot!

If anyone is visiting New York, or if the homebodies need a recommendation, this place is LIT.