Mama Theresa's, Garden City Park NY

Came back after a year and the employee over the counter is coughing all over without coughing into his arm! Even coughed by the garlic knots. We had to walk right out that’s completely disgusting!

Great pizza but they have been looking smaller and Sicilian pies have less slices. They also forgot my utensils when I ordered a large amount of food for a party. The lady on the phone is Italian with a thick accent which makes you feel good when ordering but it’s so thick ordering was hard and had to repeat multiple times.

This place has the absolute BEST chicken Parm dinner, chicken marsala dinner, penne Ala vodka, plain slice, marsala slice, Buffalo slice I've ever had. They are so good it's almost upsetting. How can you be this good? How? ! Seriously- they are the best. Excellent take out/ pick up or dine in service. The ambiance isn't anything to write home about, just a busy hometown pizzeria with some comfortable booths if you want to stay. Danny is the man. The whole staff is honestly just stellar. During COVID their pickup line never stopped- it was always out the door. You know why? Because they are THE BEST. GET A MARSALA SLICE and when it rocks your world, tell Danny, Big John sent ya

Best pesto ever- no cream, straight up basil etc and house salads with mozz - all time fav!

Ordered dinner to pick up on my way home from work. The restaurant is about 30 minutes from my house. I asked the counter staff to confirm my order was correct and prepared in accordance with my food allergies. I was told it was. Come home and find out it was not. I was told I can come drive back 30 mins and get a new order or I can have my name in a credit book for next time I ordered. They claim they cannot refund my credit card. I stopped eating there regularly due to other changes made and poor service.

Excellent excellent excellent. I have the eggplant Parm very often and for the first time last week I tried the pecan salad. It is now my go-to salad. I've had it twice since first trying it. And excellent each time.

I got a slice today on lunch, I always see people shuffling in and out so I figured it cant be horrible. My stomach is killing me an hour later, I have never felt so awful after a plain slice. The plain slice was almost $4 as well, which just adds insult to injury.

Go up Jericho to Umbertos, its a bit cheaper and much better.

Been going here since 1993. Food quality plummeted a few years ago. Small portions and exuberant prices. Not worth it anymore. It’s really a shame because it use to be great.

Ordered a pie. Half cheese half pepperoni. They put pepperoni on only a quarter of the pie. Really? I would post a picture if there was an option to. You up charge for the half pepperoni and you don't even give it on all half. Ridiculous

Hands down the BEST buffalo chicken pizza I have ever had! Reheats super well in the air fryer too. I am also in love with their salad pizza. It is super vinegary with a generous amount of toppings including onions, tomatoes, and olives.

They definitely overcharge on everything
A 2 liter of soda is 7.00$ deff wouldn’t go back

A waiter lifted my daughter in a bad way from the
Table that she had chosen. The waiter was Hispanic you don't have to treat people badly. It is unfortunate because the food is delicious but I will never go back there.

First visit since pandemic buy still good and same as before. Definitely we go back next time

Melvin our server is very friendly, helpful and expedited our lunch order. The pick two is a great option because you can have a little of all their delicious food. Their salads and pizettes are delish!

Got a panini from here, it wasn’t even edible. Employees stare you down and talk about you in Spanish. Bad vibes, food I had to throw and go to another pizzeria for proper lunch. Charged me $22 for a panini and 1 slice of pizza, I just paid hoping food will be good. Worst mistake … never going back and “WARN OTHERS NOT TO WASTE YOUR MONEY” on terrible food and service.

The food was delicious. The pizzas and calzon was great, and the Sicilian. I recommend this place.