Mamma Maria New York Pizzeria Auburn

Tough, leathery pizza. Shriveled toppings. My wife and my mouths ached after chewing this pizza. Twice as long to be ready as estimated when ordered and slightly burnt. This used to be a favorite for myself and my family, very disappointed.

My business taste tested their pizzas. We took some and cook them over an open flame and they were beyond fantastic! We are excited to be doing business with them with our upcoming customers!

Owner is pizza king, dough is great plenty of toppings, the boys of Owasco marina thank you great job.

They have really good pizza, actually the best pizza in aburn, so your wondering why I gave a one star is because the OWNER unfortunately does not believe in using gloves he touches the food with his bare hands which to me is very nasty, contagious and most of all bad and unsanitary for someone to eat. I caught H-PYLORI from Kentucky fried chicken in auburn, which is a nasty bacteria from contamination. If left untreated you can get stomach cancer, now who wants that. And sadly he thinks because he is the owner he can do that and that it is okay when it is not and that it doesn't matter because he washes his and every so often, the phrase for today is "EVERY SO OFTEN" and that sucks. He wipes his hands on his clothes (apron) which is dirty. My last day eating here.

Great pizza! Friendly Service. Well taken care of location, clean and fresh atmosphere
Recommend their chicken wing & pepperoni pizza

One of my favorite places to get lunch. Big selection, pizza is always on point. Always friendly people working there. Plus some of my favorite wings in town.

We like their food a lot. We've always had good service. It's not really a place I would go for atmosphere. We really just go in and leave.

Everything and I mean everything about this place is AMAZING! Never a disappointment. Very friendly and fast service. Always polite and attentive.

Horrible pizza. The word New York shouldn’t even be in the name because it’s worse than chain pizza and I’m
from NYC so I know high quality best pizza spots. It’s rubbery and undercooked crust. They don’t know what they’re doing here and shocking how people like it. Very unpleasant service and I recommend people not go to this joint.

Friendly staff. Clean establishment. Best Pizza my wife and I have found in Central New York.

Every time I go there I buy every Pepperoni pinwheel/flower they have lol. Pizza is delicious and staff is friendly. Highly recommended

Always hunting for authentic New York style pizza, this place had alot of recommendations when I asked my fb community. It was good, but the crust was tough, and the toppings a bit sparse and not evenly distributed. On to the next pizzeria.

Such good new york style pizza. The staff is super friendly, they are quick too no matter how busy it is there's usually only a short wait time to be helped. The food is delicious and they have a pretty good selection of not only pizza and topping but also other things like breads, calzones, salads, sandwiches etc. And it's affordable! I highly recommend them

Some of the best pizza I have ever had and they gave me amazing customer service truly a great space

Definitely a great place to eat make u feel like family an the food is amazing haven't tried anything yet I didn't want more of

All the place is just great food is wonderful. Pizza is always delicious I love their Italian sandwich always on point never been disappointed

All I asked for was a garlic half baked with mozzarella and that’s exactly what I got. It was perfect. I topped it and finished it at home. They pulled the pie exactly when it was ready to travel. They were busy, happy, organized and helpful. The pizza was inexpensive and delicious! We’re going back again tonight for another!

I was Christmas shopping and got hungry so I got a slice of mushrooms and sausage it was pretty good

Great place. Wonderful pizza and all the varieties of pizzas and Italian food. Owners and staff are very pleasant. I recommend Mamma María 100 %.

Excellent fresh pizza great selection including different veggie ones, great fast service. Crust is crispy & light & slices are generously large. Absolutely recommend